Connect with us
Superman #23 Review

Comic Books

Superman #23 Review

There’s a bit of an Empire Strikes Back vibe in Superman #23, the fourth part of the “Black Dawn” arc. While Superman and Lois learn who’s really in control of Hamilton County, Jon is forced to watch his parents fight without his help. Writers Peter J. Tomasi and Patrick Gleason and artist Doug Mahnke get about as dark as a Superman book can get.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
Superman #23 Review
Superman #23
Writers: Patrick Gleason, Peter J. Tomasi
Artists: Jaime Mendoza, Doug Mahnke

Publisher: DC Comics

Here’s the official synopsis from DC Comics:

“BLACK DAWN” part four! The mysterious force behind Superman’s defeat reveals itself. Superboy wonders what is so great about Truth, Justice and the American way. Will Jon turn against his father?

In the story so far, we’ve learned that farmer Cobb, the Kents’ next-door neighbor, was not as innocent as Superman thought. He was to blame for Jonathan’s stunted superpowers. When Lois Lane got too close to the truth, the real puppetmasters of Hamilton took advantage of Superman going on his own path to find Batman, Robin and Jonathan.

Superman #23 Review

They captured Lois, likely knowing that Superman would come right after her. That’s exactly what the Big Blue Boy Scout does in #23. Even though he is right on the doorstep of the main villain in all this, he still rushes to save Lois. After the rescue, there are even more monsters to fight in the town and things really start to fit together. Superman is fighting alongside a particular group of villains who think killing is OK.

Superman #23 Review

Meanwhile, the real mastermind behind this is forcing Jon to watch everything, keeping him from helping his parents. The villain (don’t worry, I won’t spoil it) is revealed on the very last page, and it’s pretty obvious why Mahnke took over penciling for #22 and #23.

Speaking of Mahnke’s art, it’s great here and much better than last issue, which didn’t have as much action. In this issue, he takes full advantage of the dark tone of the story, bringing out the creepy world that Hamilton has become in “Black Dawn.” The optimistic, sunny world of previous Superman arcs since Rebirth is long forgotten here. I never thought I’d be freaked out by the sight of an old man in overalls.

Superman #23 Review

As for the story itself, Superman is constantly pushed to weigh his morals. “Black Dawn” has become a story about Superman forced to chose between saving strangers and his family, and even between saving his wife and saving his son. Superman even has to test his vow not to kill. Tomasi and Gleason turn up the heat on Supes and it’s going to be exciting to see how this all ends.

Superman #23 Review
Superman #23 Review
Is It Any Good?
The "Black Dawn" story reaches an exciting climax with a dark issue that splits up the Kent family and finally reveals the big villain.
Superman rebounds after last week's nearly Superman-less issue, doubling down on action.
The villain reveal will be appreciated by longtime Superman fans.
Great art by Doug Mahnke that matches the dark turn Tomasi & Gleason's story has taken.
If you expect lighter fare from Superman stories, maybe look elsewhere.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

the wheel of time the wheel of time

‘The Wheel of Time’ Episode 4 review: ‘The Dragon Reborn’


AIPT 2021 Toys Gift Guide: Hasbro, Neca, Sideshow, and more AIPT 2021 Toys Gift Guide: Hasbro, Neca, Sideshow, and more

AIPT 2021 Toys Gift Guide: Hasbro, Neca, Sideshow, and more


'Hulk' #1 review: The Hulk, my destination 'Hulk' #1 review: The Hulk, my destination

‘Hulk’ #1 review: The Hulk, my destination

Comic Books

'Black Panther' #1 gets right down to business 'Black Panther' #1 gets right down to business

‘Black Panther’ #1 gets right down to business

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup