Connect with us
'Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection' review - The right time for a genre to return?

Comic Books

‘Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection’ review – The right time for a genre to return?

Great examples of a bygone style — and some strange mash-ups by Chris Claremont.

Things are going pretty well for superheroes these days. While cultural ubiquity hasn’t exactly led to a publishing resurgence, of the comics that do get produced, capes are still dominant, and have been for 60 years.

Prior to this extended plateau of genre stability, a host of other styles paraded through the pulps, catching fire for a time before readers grew bored and ready for the next trend. In the 1970s though, bucking the superhero stranglehold, one family of books would rise from the dead for another moment under the moonlight.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection compiles many of the stories, originally published in in an oversized, black and white format, that diverged from the House of Ideas’ typical output, but at the same time highlighted some characters that would go on to dovetail back into mainstream Marvel for mass appeal.

The book opens with an uncharacteristic example — a very early Blade story written by Chris Claremont and drawn by Tony Dezuniga and Rico Rival, from Marvel Preview #3. It’s a strange mixture of Claremont’s wordy tendencies and a little bit of tragic horror tropes, but the whole is less than the sum of its disparate parts. “The Night Josie Harper Died!” ends up being more of a stilted superhero story than anything approaching the horror comics of yore. The art doesn’t help the effort, as the surprisingly light inks make it difficult to discern the action scenes.

Claremont’s gotten his sea legs by the time he gets to Marvel Preview #7’s “The Damnation Waltz,” a riveting tale of Satana, the Devil’s Daughter, and her emergence from the prison of a housewife’s body, that’s evocative of Rosemary’s Baby in all the best ways. This is a true horror story, as Satana is both the villain and, by the end, the hero of the story, as she defeats the even more evil cult that desires to use her for their own intents. Artist Vicente Alcazar nails it, too, with heavy inks and trippy layouts indicating Satana’s resurgence.

'Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection' review - The right time for a genre to return?

It makes the failure of “By Virtue of Blood!” from Bizarre Adventures #25 weirder, as Claremont seems to think incessant narration over photos of the Hindenburg somehow makes a good story. There isn’t a single line of dialogue until the fourth page, and the art contributed by Michael Golden can’t even come close to carrying the narrative. The total story is only 14 pages, but even though not much happens, it feels three times that length. Horror comics shouldn’t be a slog to push through.

Thankfully, most of the rest of Marvel Horror fulfills its promise. The shorter stories more capably build and release tension and better hold the readers attention. Marv Wolfman’s eight-page Blade story from Marvel Preview #8, “Into the House of Terror!” is everything Claremont’s wishes it could be — a truly disturbing look at a day in the life of a vampire hunter. It doesn’t hurt that Gene Colan is there to add ethereal ambiance and ghastly facial expressions.

The last character that might be familiar to regular Marvel readers is Gabriel the Devil Hunter, presented here by Doug Moench in Haunt of Horror #2. It’s the first appearance of a character with a lot of potential — a man who’s been burned by religion but still fights its nastiest threats — who will be best known to most for his appearances in the 1990s Hellstorm series. Artist Billy Graham (how’s that for irony!) makes great use of shadows and angled panels to set the scenes and push the story forward.

'Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection' review - The right time for a genre to return?

Moench and Wolfman contribute more stories to Marvel Horror, and they’re more in the vein of what you expect — creepy morality tales that make the reader question who and what is right. Kit Pearson, Bruce Jones, Steve Skeates, Doug McGregor, and even Steve Gerber and Gerry Conway join in the fun, with Moench’s “Tales of the Zombie,” drawn by Dave Simons, being a standout for its gleeful annihilation of almost every character and its detailed yet appropriately sleazy pencils.

The most unexpected gem in this collection is five one-page stories by Tony Isabella, originally appearing in Monsters Unleashed, each describing a supposedly “real” monster from folklore or eyewitness sightings. And it’s not just Bigfoot and Nessie — there is a story on sea serpents and one on the Thunderbird, but who remembers Peter Snubb, the Atomic Monster of Michigan or the 12th century Burning Man of Germany’s Black Forest?

It can be hard to judge a collection of 40-year-old works through a modern lens, but it helps to consider the zeitgeist of when they were produced and if the stories meet the expectations of the time and style. Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection largely succeeds in that regard, only really stumbling in the most unexpected places — in Claremont’s issues and Perry’s retelling of Dracula’s origin. The other, shorter, hard-to-find tales are great examples, though, and to a fan of classic comic horror, they’re probably worth the $34.99 on their own.

'Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection' review - The right time for a genre to return?
Marvel Horror: The Magazine Collection
Is it good?
It has some fine examples of the classic horror comic style, but the longer stories may be tough for modern readers to slog through.
Claremont's Satana story
Blade in a real horror setting, by Marv Wolfman
"Tales of the Zombie" by Doug Moench and Dave Simons
Neat "real monster" stories by Tony Isabella
Fun look into a bygone style
Claremont's other stories
Steve Perry's "The Blood Bequest" has an impactful ending/beginning for Dracula, but takes a while to get there
May be too "talky" for modern readers
The black and white art soars when done well, but severely limits the narrative when not

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

DC Preview: Nightwing #78 - out March 16 DC Preview: Nightwing #78 - out March 16

DC Preview: Nightwing #78 – out March 16

Comic Books

X-Men (2019-) #18 X-Men (2019-) #18

Marvel Preview: X-Men #18

Comic Books

Marvel Preview: Marvel's Voices: Legacy #1 Marvel Preview: Marvel's Voices: Legacy #1

Marvel Preview: Marvel’s Voices: Legacy #1

Comic Books

Marvel Preview: Amazing Spider-Man #60 Marvel Preview: Amazing Spider-Man #60

Marvel Preview: Amazing Spider-Man #60

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup