Connect with us
Abbott #4 Review

Comic Books

Abbott #4 Review

She’s out of a job, but that won’t keep Elena Abbott from working the case.

Abbott #4 follows Elena Abbott as she tries to gather as many allies as she can against the dark forces hunting her and potentially threatening the world. Facing horrific chimeras of animals fused with dead human spirits, she’ll need all the help she can get to restore balance to the light and the dark. Does this issue move the mystery forward in an interesting way?

For the most part, yes. I’ll start with what few gripes I have to get them out of the way. At this point in the series we’ve more or less completely lost the noir feeling I was getting from the first two issues and the series feels a lot more like suspenseful urban fantasy. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but I loved the mood of the earlier issues and wish it had maintained throughout the series. I think that shift ties into my other main critique. The plot of Abbott is, barring a major twist at the end, fairly predictable. Without spoiling anything, it was clear what the fate of a certain character was and Abbott’s use of her camera against the evils spirits that attack her is beginning to feel repetitive. I like the metaphor of Abbott bringing evil things to light literally and figuratively, spiritually, and politically, but the actual mechanic has gone a little stale. I appreciate that it seems like that will be played with in the coming final issue.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Abbott #4 Review

All that being said, I continue to not have enough good to say about the characterization in this series. Writer Saladin Ahmed gives each character such distinct personalities, even if they appear in one scene and likely won’t be seen again. Not only do the characters sound real, they feel real in that they each have their own motivations, goals, and beliefs that don’t always line up conveniently with Abbott’s. This puts certain characters at odds with our protagonist in ways that make it clear that they aren’t going to conveniently bend their will to the plot for the sake of a neat resolution. This especially comes through Amelia and her scene with Abbott in this issue makes me hungry for an Amelia-centric spinoff story. Ahmed also continues to shine when it comes to portraying the racial dynamics of 1970s Detroit, refusing to shy away from a lot of ugly behaviors that found their roots in earlier years which grew thicker and thicker as time went on.

Sami Kivelä continues to deliver stunning line art in this issue. Faces are expressive, backgrounds are detailed and clean, and the monsters are terrifyingly gorgeous. One of the aforementioned chimeras featuring a lion’s body looks ferocious and foul and the ghoulish smoke that always accompanies these demons continues to set the tone expertly. Jason Wordie’s colors bring the line art to life in gradients that continue to make the world of Abbott feel alive and convey the shifting nature of its balance between light and dark well. Without the newspaper clippings book-ending the issue as in the past three, we see a bit less of Jim Campbell’s letters, but he does a great job with supernatural elements like the chimeras’ growls that travel outside the word balloon.

Abbott #4 Review

Before I finish, I have to mention the excellent paneling done in this issue. The layouts are so clever and whether they are a result of the script or choices made by Kivelä, I applaud the team for thinking outside the box this way. Overall, though I have some complaints about the mood and some plot details, the series continues to feature great characters, stunning art, and important themes that have always been timely and feel incredibly prevalent today.

Abbott #4 Review
Abbott #4
Is it good?
Though there are a couple details I don’t love, the series continues to shine through excellent characterization and gorgeous artwork.
Saladin Ahmed gives every character a distinct voice with clear motivations that won’t be swayed for the sake of convenience.
Artist Sami Kivelä continues to deliver gorgeous pencils and inks from faces, to backgrounds, to nightmarish creatures.
The page layouts employ some clever techniques that play with the panels in interesting ways.
Jason Wordie’s colors shift in gradients that parallel the series' themes well.
The mood has completely shifted away from the noir feeling of the earlier issues.
Certain elements of the plot are very predictable, though some of this appears to be changing in the coming finale.

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today

In Case You Missed It

'Amazing Spider-Man' #25 review: Peter and Mary Jane are never, ever getting back together 'Amazing Spider-Man' #25 review: Peter and Mary Jane are never, ever getting back together

‘Amazing Spider-Man’ #25 review: Peter and Mary Jane are never, ever getting back together

Comic Books

Creator-led 'Black Box Chronicles' comes to Kickstarter May 16 - exclusive Creator-led 'Black Box Chronicles' comes to Kickstarter May 16 - exclusive

Creator-led ‘Black Box Chronicles’ comes to Kickstarter May 16 – exclusive

Comic Books

Wonder Woman’s daughter, Trinity, to be introduced in 'Wonder Woman' #800 Wonder Woman’s daughter, Trinity, to be introduced in 'Wonder Woman' #800

Wonder Woman’s daughter, Trinity, to be introduced in ‘Wonder Woman’ #800

Comic Books

Hal looking cocky in Green Lantern #1 Hal looking cocky in Green Lantern #1

‘Green Lantern’ #1 simply brings the Lanterns back to their roots

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup