Connect with us
'Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3' review: blending superheroes with pulp horror

Comic Books

‘Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3’ review: blending superheroes with pulp horror

Ghost Rider, Spider-Woman, and Iron Man and more team up with the werewolf in this final collection.

The final Complete Collection trade paperback of Werewolf By Night is arriving in comic book shops today, detailing the harrowing adventures of a man who is also a monster. This volume details an interesting reality where night and day are divided, has superhero team-ups with Iron Man and Spider-Woman, and throws in some new with the old Moon Knight adventures.

So what’s it about?

The official summary reads:

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Complete your collection of the classic adventures of Marvel’s legendary lycanthrope! But can even Jack Russell survive when he battles the silver-clad stalker known as Moon Knight? There are plenty more candidates lining up to wrestle the Werewolf — including Hangman, Brother Voodoo, Iron Man and Fire-Eyes, the man with the gaze of doom! But will Spider-Woman be a friend or a fearsome foe? Jack has faced super heroes and supernatural threats; now he and Spider-Man — and Ghost Rider, too — will learn that no villain is more vile than…Tatterdemalion! Plus: Witness the savage rematch between Moon Knight and the Werewolf!

Why does this matter?

This is third and last volume in this complete collection series so if you’re a completist you’re going to want this. This book also has some fun classic hero appearances from Spider-Woman, Iron Man, and Ghost Rider just to name a few.

Plus we rather liked Volume 1 and Volume 2.

'Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3' review: blending superheroes with pulp horror

Watch out Cyclops! From Werewolf By Night (1972) #41

Fine, you have my attention. What’s good about it?

Jack Russell is a reluctant hero who learns how to control his powers even though he doesn’t want them. In this collection, he goes on some insane adventures including a team up with Iron Man and a battle with Moon Knight (who share themes in a way). There are also cosmic battles including a strange exploration of another world where night is always going and day too. This is a very wordy trade that will be a must for folks who have purchased the previous two volumes, but it’s more of a slice of history and still a totally enjoyable experience if you dive in here first. The art is good — the Spider-Man issue in particular — and there are plenty of pulpy moments that capture the era.

A chapter that is possibly worth the price of admission alone involves a caper with Ghost Rider (who makes two appearances in this volume), Morbius, and Man-Thing confronting a golden man who is human perfection. This tale is an interesting story as it reveals humankind split off and was kidnapped by aliens and sent into space where they evolved. The twist on this, that Los Angeles once housed a separate society torn away from our ancestors, is a clever tale and it brandished an interesting twist as the human/alien reveals the true selves of each monster. Its classic sci-fi meets supernatural in a fun way.

The Moon Knight issues at the back of this collection were published originally in 1982 and are drawn by Bill Sienkiewicz. These issues are clearly much more modern visually, with a striking style that is actually quite scary. It has a dark style similar to later Maxx artist Sam Keith. They’re gritty and modern, playing with the wild nature of the Wolfman and have a dark tone newer readers will appreciate. It’s hard to believe much of the earlier issues collected here were published in the ’70s, not too long before Sienkiewicz’s work, yet they harbor an overused and somewhat boring style in comparison. Moon Knight has a much closer look at what we know and love too and he looks very cool in this story.

'Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3' review: blending superheroes with pulp horror

One of the more action packed chapters. From Marvel Premiere #59.

It can’t be perfect can it?

This is a dense read. There are issues within that are difficult to get through because characters are so verbose or the minutiae of the internal monologue is never-ending. It can be especially monotonous when the story retreads the character’s fear of turning and frustration of his burden. I can imagine these comics were hugely popular at the time, but werewolves really aren’t in fashion anymore. That said, it’s interesting to see a wolfman integrated into normal MCU stories. Unfortunately, he’s rather boring with little development and serves as a cliched reluctant hero over and over rather than an interesting character. Some of the predicaments he’s thrust into in this volume are fun though, and you can’t deny the supernatural elements as unique all their own.

Is it good?

One of the coolest clashes between pulp horror and superheroes I’ve ever read. It definitely shows its age with its art and slow pace, but it makes up for that with fun supernatural twists and turns. There are at least three must-read stories in this collection, which is a win in my book. That said, at 464 pages there may not be enough value here for many.

'Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3' review: blending superheroes with pulp horror
Werewolf By Night: The Complete Collection Vol. 3
Is it good?
A story or two will capture your imagination in this sometimes fun blast from the past.
A couple excellent stories and some fun team ups and cameos
Bill Sienkiewicz's section has some of the coolest art in the whole book
Cool to read older comics and see how much they've changed
A dense read that is paced incredibly slowly (for the most part)
The main character's schtick gets a bit old after awhile though there are some changes to his character here
6.5
Good

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

'Fall River' identifies another victim of the Satanic Panic 'Fall River' identifies another victim of the Satanic Panic

‘Fall River’ identifies another victim of the Satanic Panic

Television

Marvel announces Taylor and Coello's 'Dark Ages' for September 2021 Marvel announces Taylor and Coello's 'Dark Ages' for September 2021

Marvel announces Taylor and Coello’s ‘Dark Ages’ for September 2021

Comic Books

Nick Spencer to leave 'Amazing Spider-Man' after issue #74 Nick Spencer to leave 'Amazing Spider-Man' after issue #74

Nick Spencer to leave ‘Amazing Spider-Man’ after issue #74

Comic Books

DC Preview: Batman: Reptilian #1 DC Preview: Batman: Reptilian #1

DC Preview: Batman: Reptilian #1

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup