Connect with us
Marvel Knights:  Marvel Boy review -- Half insect, halfhearted

Comic Books

Marvel Knights: Marvel Boy review — Half insect, halfhearted

Some prescient ideas sandwiched with a mundane narrative.

Grant Morrison can be a polarizing figure in comics. He’s got big ideas, and his own unique style, things that soar in his creator-owned work, but can make longtime fans of more established properties bristle when he wildly flips the script on their favorites.

The early 2000s were a polarizing time in comics, especially at Marvel. After battling bankruptcy, the company had taken a “back to basics” approach, with character-focused storytelling, while at the same time throwing tons of different sh*t against the wall to see what would stick.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Enter Joe Quesada, Jimmy Palmiotti and the Marvel Knights line. Entrusted to bring certain characters forward into the future and be deliberately experimental, their handpicked creators did amazing things with Daredevil, Black Panther and others that still resonate today. They also greenlit Angel Punisher.

Then there was Grant Morrison’s six-issue Marvel Boy series in the year 2000, which examined new characters in the old sandbox. Where on the spectrum of groundbreaking to repulsive does that land?

Marvel Knights:  Marvel Boy review -- Half insect, halfhearted
Image credit: Marvel Comics

Without burying the lede, it’s squarely in the middle. Marvel Boy, reprinted this month in trade paperback form, is the tale of Noh-Varr, a character that would be used to great effect later on by Brian Michael Bendis and Kieron Gillen, in ways that are almost unrecognizable from his original formulation.

Under Morrison’s pen, Noh-Varr is a borderline anarchist Kree teenager from another universe, seemingly pulled here by the nefarious Dr. Midas in some really neat scenes that speak of probabilities collapsing, as his interdimensional ship finally decides the main Marvel Universe is where they need to be. Everyone Varr knows and loves dies in the process, so add a little torture, and he’s ready to literally go scorched earth on us all. 

So he uses a bunch of cool powers, including a “white run” and his famous hybrid insect physiology, to do what all supervillains do — tear New York City a new a**hole. I’m swearing a lot because that’s Noh-Varr’s main objective in all this, to emblazon curse words across Midtown, apparently.

That, and his desire to just kick back and veg after a hard day’s destruction, really do paint Noh-Varr as a unique and terrifying thing — an arrogant prick of a teenager with enough world-beating power to play out his worst instincts.

Marvel Knights:  Marvel Boy review -- Half insect, halfhearted
Image credit: Marvel Comics

He softens a bit in the third issue, where he takes on a depressingly prescient enemy, the sentient mega-corporation, Hexus. Also known as Brand Hex, Hexus pillages a planet of its resources before sporing back into space and leaving the empty, resource-drained shell behind. It’s a terrifying and all-too real threat that’s ripe for someone else to pick up and use again.

Following the boundless creativity and trademark Morrison dialogue in the first half of Marvel Boy is a stunningly average second half that could have been written by any interchangeable staffer. Varr switches on a dime to becoming Earth’s protector for reasons that aren’t clear at all, and his adversaries are a lot less fleshed-out than you might have been led to believe, if you haven’t read it.

The knock-off Iron Man suit of Dr. Midas is never really explained, and his standard mustache-twirling plot is beyond lame after the genuinely novel stuff that came before.  And for a damaged woman dressed in bondage gear, Exterminatrix doesn’t have much of a personality. Even the psychological reveal is telegraphed and one-note.

Artist J.G. Jones (with help from Ryan Kelly in issue #6) turns in a similarly perfunctory effort. It’s leagues beyond the worst of the ’90s stuff, and there is some good realism to it, but there’s really nothing about the pencils that stands out, either. Ditto for the colors of Avalon Studios and Matt Milla, which serve the story fine, but never really make you take notice.

Most people either love or hate Morrison’s work. Marvel Boy is the rare case where one person can feel both those emotions within the span of six issues.  If you’ve wondered why this one gets overlooked, it could be because no one really knows what to make of it. Folks might complain that current iterations of Noh-Varr don’t ring true to Morrison’s original vision, but that clearly wasn’t consistent to begin with.

It’s good that modern writers have this weird character to mold and play with going forward, but the story that birthed him is anything but essential. For completionists only, unless you’re a creator looking to pick up on that whole living corporation thread.

Marvel Knights: Marvel Boy
Is it good?
It's halfway good, and halfway average. "Marvel Boy" starts out as something novel, and becomes something normal and boring. Good if you're looking for the origins of Noh-Varr, but inessential otherwise.
Some good Morrison dialogue and great ideas in the beginning ...
The art is nice and a step up from the worst of the '90s ...
The original concepts of these characters are interesting ...
... but the narrative gets super pedestrian in the second half.
... but it's not anything that will blow you away, either.
... but they fall short of their potential by story's end. Still fertile ground for other writers to use them, though.
6.5
Good

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

Mandalorian Jeans Guy Mandalorian Jeans Guy

The Mandalorian: Jean-clad crew member crashes Chapter 12 (and steals our hearts)

Star Wars

Rating X-Men's swollest lads based on total niceness Rating X-Men's swollest lads based on total niceness

Rating X-Men’s swollest lads based on total niceness

Comic Books

X-Men Monday Call for Questions - Jonathan Hickman X-Men Monday Call for Questions - Jonathan Hickman

X-Men Monday Call for Questions – Jonathan Hickman

Comic Books

AIPT Comics Podcast Episode 99: Talkin' TKO series 'The Pull' with writer Steve Orlando AIPT Comics Podcast Episode 99: Talkin' TKO series 'The Pull' with writer Steve Orlando

AIPT Comics Podcast Episode 99: Talkin’ TKO series ‘The Pull’ with writer Steve Orlando

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup