Connect with us
Jimmy Olsen #4 review

Comic Books

Jimmy Olsen #4 review

Matt Fraction and Steve Lieber pack a ton into each issue–especially this one.

We’re only on issue #4? Gosh, it feels like this series has been going on for ages. Anywho, Jimmy Olsen #4 picks up with our plucky hero still in Gotham trying to convince Lois Lane of a grand conspiracy involving Lex Luthor. Also, Jimmy, now Timmy, wreaks havoc across Gotham as an ambulance-chasing shock jock.

Jimmy Olsen #4 review
DC Comics

My opening statement isn’t an insult — I said that because Matt Fraction and Steve Lieber pack a ton into each issue. It’s exhausting to keep up, not only with each individual issue, but also trying to remember and tie everything back to previous installments. #4 is especially whirlwind-like since it recaps much of what happened earlier. Of course, that’s done via Jimmy with a “crazy board” a la Charlie from It’s Always Sunny….

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
Jimmy Olsen #4 review
FX

While it doesn’t sound terribly exciting to have this issue’s gimmick be exposition via cork-board, Fraction and Lieber find ways around that, like spending the other half of the issue on Family Guy-esque cutaways to illustrate Jimmy’s cartoonish ranting. This allows the creative team to manspread out with gags ranging from Lex Luthor piloting a helicopter to noir-inspired meetings in parking garages. I complained about previous issues dragging on with unnecessary Joachim Olsen segments, but finally Fraction explains their inclusion and incorporates them in a meaningful way.

As previously mentioned, there’s a thread coming through that Jimmy, now Timmy, is reveling in his newfound identity and chasing hits to destructive ends. This is an interesting theme and character idea: seeing a darker side to Jimmy’s usual Chaotic Good. Maybe something lurks within that’s more neutral or…evil? Well, maybe that’s too strong, but he’s certainly acting selfish as Timmy. Unfortunately, Jimmy and Lois have to spell that out for us in dialogue. But since this series has a comedic tone, that’s more forgivable. Exposition is a big part of comedy after all. Hopefully they continue to work on this thread, since there’s so much potential here.

Jimmy Olsen #4 review
DC Comics

Steve Lieber isn’t handed a script with as much visual verve as other issues. But he’s such a fantastic artist, especially dealing with comedy, that he makes interior exposition scenes fly by. Yet, when he draws cutaway gags that require scope, he adds just the right amount of details to convince us of the scale but not enough to make the visual jokes unwieldy. Might I add that his character expressions in #4 are better than ever (just look at these preview pages).

Despite not having the referential power of #3, this issue simultaneously keeps the momentum and scatterbrain pacing racing along.

Jimmy Olsen #4 review
Jimmy Olsen #4
Is it good?
Despite not having the referential power of #3, this issue simultaneously keeps the momentum and scatterbrain pace racing along.
Steve Lieber's comedy chops.
Fraction makes exposition exciting.
Wanted more nuance from Timmy subplot.
7
GOOD

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today
Comments

In Case You Missed It

Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden

‘Banishers: Ghosts of New Eden’ is the next story-driven RPG you are looking for

Gaming

Time travel: the only way is forward Time travel: the only way is forward

Time travel: the only way is forward

Science

Chip Zdarsky was the first choice to write 'Ultimate Spider-Man' 2024 Chip Zdarsky was the first choice to write 'Ultimate Spider-Man' 2024

Chip Zdarsky was the first choice to write ‘Ultimate Spider-Man’ 2024

Comic Books

Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers: The Return #1 Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers: The Return #1

‘Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Return’ #1 lives up to its name

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup