Connect with us
'Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing' review
Marvel

Comic Books

‘Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing’ review

The melodramatic lives of Mary Jane and Peter Parker continue in ‘Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane’.

Completists take note: the follow-up to last year’s Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Unexpected Thing is out this week in comic book shops, carrying the beloved series to its end. This is a reprint of the original collection but now in digest format for smaller hands. Collecting Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane #14-20 and Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane Season 2 #1-5, readers are privy to intense love triangles, Firestar showing up to throw a wrench into all that, and primo Mary Jane drama you can’t get anywhere else. It’s the perfect book for teenagers who want a touch of superheroes.

And a touch of superheroes is what you’ll get. Spider-Man shows up, naturally, but he’s only here or there for Mary Jane to speak to or reflect on as he thwips through the city. Firestar adds a bit more heroics with Spidey, but really this is Mary Jane’s book. The meat of this series takes its main focus on Mary Jane, but other characters like Harry Osborn, Gwen Stacy, Felicia Hardy, and Flash Thompson all get moments to shine. Set during high school, this is an original take on the characters that’s 100% focused on the dating lives and troubles high schoolers can connect with.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

This volume starts with a secret that eventually blows up and causes some pain for characters. At the start, only Gwen Stacy knows Peter is Spider-Man, which is partly Peter’s fault as he’s avoided telling Mary Jane. In the first volume, he abstained from telling her to make sure she was interested in Peter and not the hero, but that blew up in his face. Much of the first half of this book is about characters gossiping a bit in school about Peter’s secret, but of course, most of them don’t know the truth. This puts Peter in a bad spot since he assumes they mean he’s a hero when that’s not the case, and it ends up creating interesting conflict.

Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane

This is a lot of he said she said.
Credit: Marvel Comics

Younger readers are going to enjoy this far more than adults — it’s schlocky drama to be sure. But if you’ve ever watched a soap opera you can get the gist. Sean McKeever has a great handle on writing kids this age and you’ll believe every emotional outbreak and overreaction. Mary Jane is the heart of this book, literally and figuratively. She’s kind, thoughtful, and honest, which is more than you can say about most characters. She grounds the book and makes it feel wholesome.

Fans of Spider-Man will love how McKeever and artists David Hahn and Takeshi Miyazawa weave in nods to the original series. Felicia acts the part of high energy and flirty while Norman has a scary temper and can’t really be trusted. Flash is a bully, but deep down he means well. It’s a nice reflection of who these characters are in a new high school narrative.

The mix of Miyazawa and Hahn works well to add an endearing and fun vibe to the book. Mary Jane is wholesome and easy to connect with thanks to her expressive facial expressions. If you’ve read the last two volumes you’ll be right at home with the first chunk of this book thanks to the cartoony, manga feel to the book.

This also collects Terry Moore and Craig Rousseau’s Season 2. The art style is far different, but suits the high school setting. This five-part story suffers a bit as it has to follow such a strong soap opera. Acting class, confrontations between Peter and Flash, and even a student who has made a website to disparage and gossip about others occur in this chunk of the book. It doesn’t have the up and down nature of the melodrama in the main series to carry your interest, however.

This is a good volume, though it has its failings. The “Season 2” doesn’t live up to the main series and the narrative is certainly written for young teens more than adults. Having said that, Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing is a great gift for the middle school reader in your life.

'Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing' review
‘Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing’ review
Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing
This is a good volume though it has its failings. The "Season 2" doesn't live up to the main series and the narrative is certainly written for young teens more than adults. Having said that, Spider-Man Loves Mary Jane: The Secret Thing is a great gift for the middle school reader in your life.
Reader Rating0 Votes
0
Opens with some big time "secrets" and melodrama
Main series has fantastic art that carries through to the end
The "Season 2" doesn't live up to the original series
Reads like it's much more for younger readers than the last volume
7
Good

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

'Spooky Archeology' uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more 'Spooky Archeology' uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more

‘Spooky Archeology’ uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more

Books

the dark and the wicked the dark and the wicked

Another Take: ‘The Dark and the Wicked’ review: A suspenseful guilt trip

Movie Reviews

'Sonic the Hedgehog' #37 review 'Sonic the Hedgehog' #37 review

‘Sonic the Hedgehog’ #37 review

Comic Books

Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy #6 Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy #6

‘Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy’ #6 review

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup