Connect with us
X-Men Legends #1
Marvel Comics

Comic Books

‘X-Men Legends’ #1 review

X-Men Legends #1 has a nostalgic feel to it despite its 2021 publication date.

Back in 1993, Fabian Nicieza and Andy Kubert published “A Tale of the X-Men,” in which Mister Sinister drops a vague hint about Scott Summers’ family. He talks about “brothers” in the plural sense, the first hint readers ever got about there being more Summers brothers than just Scott and Alex. Once Ed Brubaker and Trevor Hairsine created X-Men: Deadly Genesis in 2005, readers finally got to find out who the third Summers brother Sinister alluded to was: Gabriel Summers. But the mystery didn’t end there.

In 1994, Nicieza and Terry Dodson created X-Men #39. In this story, titled “Birds of a Feather,” Nicieza laid the seeds of who he wanted to be the third Summers brother, Adam X. The issue revolves around how Adam saves Philip Summers, Scott and Alex’s grandfather. While Adam’s parentage isn’t touched on here, it’s clear what Nicieza is doing: Philip comments how similar he is to Scott and Alex, how he feels like family, etc. For a while it seemed the Adam X question would remain just that, as no one outside of Nicieza really seemed to care about this plotline — that is, until X-Men: Legends. 

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
X-Men #39

Marvel Comics

X-Men: Legends #1 isn’t an easy read if you don’t know the lore behind this character, as several story beats from ’90s X-Men (particularly Adam X’s lore) are mentioned. Fortunately, the comic employs the ’90s technique of editors notes, directing readers to important issues; this is a practice the current X-line should employ as it continues to expand, in all honesty.

Nicieza’s writing feels plucked right out of his old run, and he proves he still knows the voices of these characters quite well. Scott and Alex sound just like the two characters people have known and loved for years, and of course, Adam X seems the same on his end as well. The art, however, is unfortunately quite noisy. For certain longtime X-readers who don’t vibe with the vast directional change of the Hickman-era X-Men line, X-Men Legends probably feels like a breath of fresh air in many ways.

Reading X-Men Legends #1 has a nostalgic feel to it despite its 2021 publication date, with the characters and setting feeling reminiscent to greeting an old friend you’ve lost contact with. It’s a trip down memory lane in its own right, the X-Men before Scott and Emma took the school, before Utopia, before Krakoa.

It’s hard to imagine this story won’t have some bearing in the Krakoa era, as one of the “Sinister Secrets” portions of House of X alluded to another Summers sibling outside of Scott, Alex, and Gabriel — Adam X felt like the obvious (yet admittedly lackluster) choice. The sad truth is Adam X simply feels unneeded and unexciting now that Gabriel is in the picture.

By the issue’s end, a major question has been answered — or has it? It’s clear there’s more to this story. For further questions, readers will simply have to wait for issue #2, but the reveal will undoubtedly have massive consequences moving forward for the Summers family. It’s certainly exciting to see this mystery finally unfold if nothing else.

X-Men Legends #1
‘X-Men Legends’ #1 review
X-Men Legends #1
Reading X-Men Legends #1 has a nostalgic feel to it despite its 2021 publication date, with the characters and setting feeling reminiscent to greeting an old friend you've lost contact with. It's a trip down memory lane in its own right.
Reader Rating2 Votes
Nicieza's voice for the characters is still great.
The book feels nostalgic, from its setting to its characters' voices and plot.
Finally seeing this 30 year old question unfold is exciting in its own right.
The Legends imprint feels like a good way to appease old fans who may not be happy with the massive changes of the Krakoa era, giving them something more familiar.
The art is noisy
The big reveal is honestly lackluster

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

the dark and the wicked the dark and the wicked

Another Take: ‘The Dark and the Wicked’ review: A suspenseful guilt trip

Movie Reviews

'Sonic the Hedgehog' #37 review 'Sonic the Hedgehog' #37 review

‘Sonic the Hedgehog’ #37 review

Comic Books

the vigil the vigil

‘The Vigil’ review: Slow burn horror will make you want to keep the lights on

Movie Reviews

Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy #6 Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy #6

‘Skulldigger and Skeleton Boy’ #6 review

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup