Connect with us
'Batman/Catwoman' #4 pushes Phantasm to center stage
DC Comics

Comic Books

‘Batman/Catwoman’ #4 pushes Phantasm to center stage

The central narrative across the book’s three timeline has started to come together, giving Phantasm a prominent role.

Four issues into Batman/Catwoman, the twelve-part maxiseries from writer Tom King and artist Clay Mann, the central narrative has started to come together across the book’s three timelines.

In the future, the child of Bruce Wayne and Selina Kyle investigates her mother’s connection to the Joker. In the present, Phantasm holds Selina hostage in an effort to track down the Joker. And, in the past, Bruce and Selina’s evening plans are interrupted when the Joker threatens to bomb Gotham World’s Fair.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

The past timeline is easily the weakest. For one, the characters look similar enough to their present incarnations for there to be considerable confusion when King switches between the present and past. (In one crucial scene, I had not realized King had switched periods until reading the page over a few times.)

The future timeline has the best narrative potential, given the work King has already done to sketch out that potential future in Batman Annual #2. In that issue — one of the better stories from his long Batman run — we were introduced to Bruce and Selina’s child, Helena, who grows up to become Batgirl.

Batman/Catwoman #4

DC Comics

The other mysterious character who gets most of this issue’s page-time is Phantasm, a fan-favorite villain from Batman: Mask of the Phantasm. I loved the movie and enjoy the way she’s portrayed here, with blue eyes and a gray suit that make her appear like some kind of cyborg. Letterer Clayton Cowles gives her word balloons the right degree of menace, coloring them black with a gray outline.

As with most of King’s recent work, I couldn’t shake the feeling while reading this issue that it would be better consumed in a collected edition. We never get enough progress in any of the three time periods to develop a sense of momentum. Some seemingly important events, like Selina’s cat squaring off with Penguin’s penguin in the future, don’t register much of an impact.

Looking back at this work when it’s completed, I’m sure the various interludes will arrive at a sharp thematic resolution. King has a good handle on the Selina/Bruce dynamic and his Batman run — however controversial it was in some corners of the internet — will always resonate for me because of how he pushed that relationship to the fore.

The drawbacks to that run — pacing issues, a dearth of action — are still present here. As AIPT’s Vishal Gullapalli wrote in a review of Batman/Catwoman #1, “If the strengths of King’s original run on Batman stood out to you more than the weaknesses, the gap will be wider here. If the weaknesses of the run were far more noticeable than any strengths, that gap will also be wider here.”

I put myself in the former camp, anxious to see what more King has to say about the couple that defined his Batman run. I just hope — as I did reading the monthly Batman book — that he picks up the pace soon.

'Batman/Catwoman' #4 pushes Phantasm to center stage
‘Batman/Catwoman’ #4 pushes Phantasm to center stage
Batman/Catwoman #4
This twelve-issue wrap-up to Tom King's long 'Batman' run is as engrossing and flawed as his monthly issues. But the three-timeline structure lends itself to some pacing problems.
Reader Rating4 Votes
Clay Mann and colorist Tomeu Morey create a perfect Phantasm.
Tom King's handle on the Bruce Wayne/Selina Kyle dynamic remains great.
Slow pacing remains a problem with the story spread across multiple timelines.
Catwoman's cat battling Penguin's penguin was a bit too on the nose for me.

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today

In Case You Missed It

Cowboy Bebop: Supernova Swing Cowboy Bebop: Supernova Swing

‘Cowboy Bebop: Supernova Swing’ review

Comic Books

X-Men Monday #172 - Steve Foxe Reflects on 'X-Men '92: House of XCII' X-Men Monday #172 - Steve Foxe Reflects on 'X-Men '92: House of XCII'

X-Men Monday #172 – Steve Foxe Reflects on ‘X-Men ’92: House of XCII’

Comic Books

'House of the Dragon' S1E5 'We Light the Way' is edge of your seat TV 'House of the Dragon' S1E5 'We Light the Way' is edge of your seat TV

‘House of the Dragon’ S1E5 ‘We Light the Way’ is edge of your seat TV


'A.X.E.: Judgment Day' #5 changes Krakoa, resurrection, and the future of the X-Men 'A.X.E.: Judgment Day' #5 changes Krakoa, resurrection, and the future of the X-Men

‘A.X.E.: Judgment Day’ #5 changes Krakoa, resurrection, and the future of the X-Men

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup