Connect with us
'The Ultimates' #17 is a deeper look at the darkness inside Doom
Marvel

Comic Books

‘The Ultimates’ #17 is a deeper look at the darkness inside Doom

A quiet, heartbreaking portrait of loss and resolve.

There are now officially only eight more issues of The Ultimates left, with The Ultimates #17 out this week, barreling towards the end of the Ultimate Universe. With so little time left and monthly jumps, there’s a lot to pack in, especially with The Maker returning soon to throw our heroes into turmoil. But turmoil is the name of the game in today’s issue, as Doom, aka a tortured Reed Richards, contemplates quitting the fight to prepare for The Maker. But why?

Mirroring issue #4, The Ultimates #17 is drawn by Phil Noto and as tragic as they come. This issue allows us to bear witness to a broken man who has lost the one thing that gave him purpose: family. A few things are juggled well here, from Doom building a program to superpower any human who wants to help fight, to Doom nearly constantly being reminded that the rest of the Fantastic Four are long gone. There are also key flashbacks to remind us of what The Maker did to Doom and how he reduced his abilities further, making the Ultimates’ mission even harder.

Possibly the most haunting element is how the rest of the Fantastic Four are depicted. They are white silhouettes, as if cut out of the comic. Smartly, writer Deniz Camp extends these silhouettes from a visual effect to something Doom literally sees in real time. It’s a haunting element, and a reminder he’s a broken man who feels like he’ll never defeat The Maker, or even come close.

An interior page from Ultimates #17

Hey Iron Lad, you’re creeping us out!
Credit: Marvel

The Maker is positively frightening in this issue, reminding us he takes glee in doing terrible things, especially torturing Doom prior to his transformation with the iron mask. A key detail of what The Maker did helps further define Doom’s twisted form, and it’s an element that certainly feels like it’ll inhibit any progress for the Ultimates.

If there’s any progress for Doom’s character, it’s how he accepts others. It’s a glimmer of hope, even if he seems damned to never get out of The Maker’s shadow. At the very least, the final panel shows kindness and a reminder that this Doom is nothing like the Doctor Doom in the 616 universe.

Speaking of progress, there are some nice touches as Iron Lad fills us in on his multi-persona adventures. He’s super freaky without any pupils, but also adamant that they can win. A couple of cutaways remind us that adventures are taking place around Doom’s experiments, though if you’re wishing for big battles or more of the Ultimates appearing, you’ve come to the wrong place.

Phil Noto’s steady, almost flat style continues to work well for this story. As a kind of two-parter, it’s nice to see the mice Doom tested on, and the silhouette effect works very well. A panel or two looks slightly underdeveloped, particularly when Doom raises a toast, but for the most part, it’s strong stuff.

The Ultimates #17 is a haunting, beautifully restrained chapter that turns away from grand battles to explore the broken soul of a man once called a hero. Deniz Camp and Phil Noto deliver a quiet powerhouse of an issue, one that uses absence, of family, of hope, of light, to devastating effect. As Ultimate Endgame looms, this story reminds us that even in defeat, Doom’s humanity burns faintly but fiercely against the Maker’s shadow.

'The Ultimates' #17 is a deeper look at the darkness inside Doom
‘The Ultimates’ #17 is a deeper look at the darkness inside Doom
The Ultimates #17
The Ultimates #17 is a haunting, beautifully restrained chapter that turns away from grand battles to explore the broken soul of a man once called a hero. Deniz Camp and Phil Noto deliver a quiet powerhouse of an issue, one that uses absence, of family, of hope, of light, to devastating effect. As Ultimate Endgame looms, this story reminds us that even in defeat, Doom’s humanity burns faintly but fiercely against the Maker’s shadow.
Reader Rating2 Votes
8.7
A powerful, introspective character study of Doom that deepens his tragedy and humanity.
Deniz Camp’s writing balances cosmic stakes with deeply personal storytelling.
The Maker’s presence looms large, injecting real menace and emotional weight.
A few panels feel unfinished or lack Noto’s usual polish, momentarily breaking immersion.
The pacing drags slightly due to the issue’s introspective focus—less action, more reflection.
8
Good
Buy Now

In Case You Missed It

Dan Panosian writes and draws 'Wolverine: Paradise' for Marvel this October 2026 Dan Panosian writes and draws 'Wolverine: Paradise' for Marvel this October 2026

Dan Panosian writes and draws ‘Wolverine: Paradise’ for Marvel this October 2026

Comic Books

Marvel's Midnight Universe gets unified launch as all three titles arrive October 7, and only those titles Marvel's Midnight Universe gets unified launch as all three titles arrive October 7, and only those titles

Marvel’s Midnight Universe gets unified launch as all three titles arrive October 7, and only those titles

Comic Books

Doctor Doom wages war on Hell in Marvel's 50-page splash-page epic Doctor Doom wages war on Hell in Marvel's 50-page splash-page epic

Doctor Doom wages war on Hell in Marvel’s 50-page splash-page epic

Comic Books

Todd McFarlane's original 1977 Spawn design finally arrives in 'Spawn 77' Todd McFarlane's original 1977 Spawn design finally arrives in 'Spawn 77'

Todd McFarlane’s original 1977 Spawn design finally arrives in ‘Spawn 77’

Comic Books

Connect