It’s hard not to notice that when the X-books want a character out of the way. They often get shipped off into space, and Jean Grey’s current role as the Phoenix fits that pattern. That’s not necessarily a bad thing; I’ve always enjoyed the cosmic side of the mutant corner of Marvel, and Jean makes sense as a character who operates in that realm. The third collection of the ongoing Phoenix title fully leans into that approach, tying big, universe-level problems to Jean’s personal ties and sense of responsibility. The ideas are solid and the scope is appropriate for the character, but the story itself doesn’t always land with as much impact as I’d like. Despite that, Phoenix is competently written and should find praise from fans of Jean Grey.
Collecting Phoenix #11–15, this volume centers on the fallout from Jean Grey’s decision to recreate her long-dead sister Sara using the Phoenix Force. What begins as a reunion quickly becomes a cosmic crisis, as the existence of Sara draws the attention of major abstract entities like Eternity and Oblivion, who view her as a threat to reality itself. Cable is thrown into the mix, as he who warns Jean that Sara’s presence may lead to catastrophic ends. As Jean struggles to balance her personal attachment against her role as the Phoenix, the story builds toward a confrontation involving past Phoenix hosts and the White Hot Room, forcing Jean to confront the limits of both her power and her choices.
Marvel
Stephanie Phillips’ strongest work here is in reinforcing Jean’s compassion and her deep loyalty to family, traits that consistently ground the story even when the stakes become intangible. The idea of turning a personal act of love into a universal problem connects well to the Phoenix entities’ existing lore, yet the book never loses sight of Jean’s emotional motivation as its central narrative focus. Key conflicts, particularly the clash between Jean and Cable, seems forced more than essential. Visually, the volume is coherent. Roi Mercado’s art handles large-scale cosmic settings well, and the White Hot Room sequences are clear and readable.
Astral Bond closes with the same tension that runs through the entire volume: big cosmic ideas paired with an ending that feels smaller than expected. Jean Grey works well in space, and this run makes a solid case for keeping her on a universal scale rather than folding her back into Earthbound X-Men stories. That said, the resolution comes together too quickly to fully capitalize on the stakes that were set up, especially given how much the book leans on the importance of Jean’s personal choices. The result is a collection that makes sense for where Jean is placed in the larger X-line, but one that ultimately feels more functional than impactful.
You must be logged in to post a comment.