Connect with us
Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review

Comic Books

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review

One sure giveaway of a well written Batman comic is a focus on his detective work. In most cases Batman uses fists to solve his problems, but he’s most intriguing when he figures things out. That requires above average writing to make it convincing, however.

Considering how popular CSI is in this country you’d think Batman would always be doing the detective thing, but let’s face it, it’s easier to write fight scenes then detective scenes. This issue is heavy on the detective work so maybe we don’t need to beg the question… is it good?

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Detective Comics (2011-) #17 (DC Comics)


Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review

Writer John Layman has been doing a bangup job on Batman the last few months. He’s adding new villains to the rogues gallery but he’s doing it from a very human and psychological place. It imbues the characters with a sense of reality and clarity most superhero comics lack.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
Sweet name for a villain.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
Similar to the Five Finger Death Punch only it’s the three tap sleep smacker. Not the best name I’ll admit.

Batman spends most of this issue piecing together who runs The League of Smiles, which is a new group of Joker knockoffs. It all stems from, as always, a corrupted psychologist. Personally I saw the twist coming a mile away, but with the way this issue reads I don’t think that’s the point. No, it’s more about how Batman thinks and pieces things together. This issue allows the reader to be a fly on the wall in order to see how Batman works and it’s done well.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
Aichmomania: A morbid desire to be punctured, perforated, or pierced with pointed objects.

When Layman mentions one of the League of Smile members has Aichmomania…I was dumbstruck. Did he make that up? Nope, it’s a real thing and it’s pretty twisted. The fact that he’s incorporating real and yet obscure psychological conditions shows he’s doing his homework.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
I need to get me one of those for work!

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
Now that’s badass!

The strongest aspect of this issue however is how badass Batman can be. The guy isn’t good simply because he can fight, but because he values knowing what’s going on. He can strut with confidence because his detective work allows him to be 100% sure.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
Clown slam!

Artist Jason Fabok continues to do his thing and I’m loving it. His work reminds me a lot of David Finch’s work on Batman: The Dark Knight as it’s detailed and well composed. Nothing is ever confusing or drawn simply to look cool. His work strengthens the story. The backup story is drawn by Andy Clarke and is similar in that it’s highly detailed. The story is a bit of a bore showing us what happened to the psychiatrist Batman was researching in the main story. It discusses obsession and manipulation of those who are mentally sick, but doesn’t offer much of anything new you probably don’t already know.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
That’s an interesting take on Arkham and would explain why none of these psychos get sent to prison.

Final Score: 8.5

Is It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #17 Review
  • Strong depiction of Batman
  • Fun detective story
  • Ho-hum backup story
  • Predictable twist

There’s a reason this comic is called Detective Comics and it’s on display here. We are witness to a Batman at his best: one who thinks before he fights. Also he’s a major badass in this issue. On top of that the art is astounding.

Is It Good?

Yes. Come for the good writing but stay a little while for the impeccable art.

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today
Comments

In Case You Missed It

WWE SmackDown preview, full card: March 1, 2024 WWE SmackDown preview, full card: March 1, 2024

WWE SmackDown preview, full card: March 1, 2024

Pro Wrestling

AEW Dynamite preview, full card: February 28, 2024 AEW Dynamite preview, full card: February 28, 2024

AEW Dynamite preview, full card: February 28, 2024

Pro Wrestling

AEW Rampage preview, full card: March 1, 2024 AEW Rampage preview, full card: March 1, 2024

AEW Rampage preview, full card: March 1, 2024

Pro Wrestling

Marvel unveils the new villains Bloodcoven appearing in 'Blood Hunt' Marvel unveils the new villains Bloodcoven appearing in 'Blood Hunt'

Marvel unveils the new villains Bloodcoven appearing in ‘Blood Hunt’

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup