Connect with us
Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review

Comic Books

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review

Here we go, part three of the ten part “Battle of the Atom” crossover. I praised the first two chapters in my reviews for being well paced, ambitious in scope and having gorgeous art. This part of the story follows two young X-Men on the run, Jean and Scott. Can author Brian Wood keep the action and excitement flowing with this issue? Is it good?


X-Men #5 (Marvel Comics)


Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

The X-Men have to formulate a plot to track down the renegade teenagers; time for a team huddle! The X-Men split into smaller groups, because well, that’s what superhero teams do in comics. Storm, being the bossy-pants she is tells her team members and equals Kitty, Rachel and Jubilee that they need to stay and hold down the fort in case Scott and Jean are to return while she boards the aircraft for the big exciting adventure. What a meanie!

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review
They just got screwed over. They’re babysitting and not even getting paid for it!

Staying with the three X-Ladies are young Bobby and Hank, because there’s no way they would want to escape the school and not have to go back in the future. Meanwhile, Storm leads a team of X-Men both future and present to look for Jean. On that mission we see the psychic dream team in action, Jean and Xavier. Next up, we visit another, smaller group of X-Men: Jean and Scott. They are stealing some clothes from a backyard which just happens to have clothes that are just their size hanging from a clothesline. Who even uses clotheslines anymore?

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review
I’ll just let the whole neighborhood watch as I change because god forbid my boyfriend and future husband would see me in my underwear!

They’re a cute little couple and their banter is pleasant to read as they motorcycle on down a highway. What’s even more fun of an interaction is that of Jean and Rachel over leftover Chinese food. Even after specific instructions to stay home, the pair decides to chase after Storm and her team of X-Buddies. Couldn’t see that one coming!

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review

I’m not going to spoil the rest of the issue for those of us who haven’t read it but I will say that there is an expected yet interesting confrontation, rather than the bombshell ending that we should expect from every issue of a crossover.

In review, this issue is very necessary to the story. It not only moves the plot along but provides us with some quality entertainment. What I didn’t much like were the numerous plot conveniences. Brian Wood is one of the best writers out there, he just can’t afford silly mistakes. Jean and Scott just happen upon a nice motorcycle in tip-top shape in a run-down, poor neighborhood? I think not. The dialogue is stellar and he gives a nice voice to all of the future X-Men, which is something I admire. Had he only focused on the present and past X-Men it would have defeated the purpose of having the future ones there in the first place. He has new and interesting characters and he is using them well.

I am new to the art of David Lopez and have to say I’m not a fan. While it’s not bad and is well-toned there are panels that just don’t look right. For example, in a number of instances Lopez just neglects to draw a face on characters:

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review

Is It Good? X-Men #5 Review 7.5

Is It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 ReviewIs It Good? X-Men #5 Review
  • Solid installment in the crossover that keeps the story progressing
  • Some great moments and dialogue
  • Chock full of plot conveniences
  • Not enough of the cover team

Is It Good?

Yes it is, but nothing more than good. Frequent plot holes and predictable twists in the story hold this issue back from being great.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

EXCLUSIVE BOOM! Preview: WWE The New Day: Power of Positivity EXCLUSIVE BOOM! Preview: WWE The New Day: Power of Positivity

EXCLUSIVE BOOM! Preview: WWE The New Day: Power of Positivity

Comic Books

Heavy Metal announces 'Chasing the Dragon' #1 sells out Heavy Metal announces 'Chasing the Dragon' #1 sells out

Heavy Metal announces ‘Chasing the Dragon’ #1 sells out

Comic Books

X-Men Monday #105 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, 'The Trial of Magneto' and More X-Men Monday #105 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, 'The Trial of Magneto' and More

X-Men Monday #105 – Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, ‘The Trial of Magneto’ and More

Comic Books

Marvel reveals new superhero and mutant Somnus to be revealed in 'Marvel's Voices: Pride' #1 Marvel reveals new superhero and mutant Somnus to be revealed in 'Marvel's Voices: Pride' #1

Marvel reveals new superhero and mutant Somnus to be revealed in ‘Marvel’s Voices: Pride’ #1

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup