Connect with us
Is It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 Review

Comic Books

Is It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 Review

Just hitting shelves now after being marketed as Astonishing Captain America almost four years ago, Andy Diggle and Adi Granov’s Captain America: Living Legend #1 shows its age when it becomes ridiculously clear that it was meant to exist in a pre-2012 Marvel universe. But is it good?


Captain America: Living Legend #1 (Marvel Comics)


captain_america_living_legend_1_cover

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Captain America: Living Legend #1 features a World War II sequence complete with Russian support, a tedious sequence spent staring at a S.H.I.E.L.D. holo-screen thingy, and a mysterious foe that’s come to bite the good Captain in his ass more than half a decade later. Sound familiar? Diggle’s story is predictable and vehemently Brubaker-esque in its tone and execution. After following Steve Rogers through Rick Remender’s crazy, 12-year romp in Dimension Z, reading such a bleak Captain America story is considerably jarring. Plus, it actually shines a spotlight on exactly why Remender decided to go for a more weird, less dark first arc.

And let’s not forget the logistical inaccuracies. Isn’t Sharon Carter dead? I know ‘continuity be damned’ and all that, but Sharon’s death was a big emotional hit and now it’s rendered less meaningful. This is an example of when wanton regard for the happenings in other titles can actually detract from both stories.

captain_america_living_legend1

Adi Granov’s artwork is stellar with each panel looking like a hand painted canvas. Granov reaches some incredible depth with facial expressions and overall use of color and shading to convey a sense of coming dread.

Is It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 Review 6.0

Is It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 ReviewIs It Good? Captain America: Living Legend #1 Review
  • Fantastic artwork by Adi Granov
  • Hearkens to a pre-Remender era of the Captain that many people immensely enjoyed.
  • Because it feels like a pre-‘Marvel NOW!’ Captain America story, it doesn’t sit as well with the current goings on.
  • Sharon Carter is alive with no explanation given.

Is it Good?

This is a decent Captain America story. Though there are some glaring flaws, those who enjoyed Brubaker’s take on the Sentinel of Liberty will love Diggle’s return to form with a tale that’s more spy thriller than dimension-hopping craziness.

 

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

what lies below what lies below

‘What Lies Below’: Body horror by way of family drama

Movie Reviews

Alex Ross blasts Warner Bros.: "I got screwed" Alex Ross blasts Warner Bros.: "I got screwed"

Alex Ross blasts Warner Bros.: “I got screwed”

Comic Books

SmackDown: The Uso family values soap opera SmackDown: The Uso family values soap opera

SmackDown: The Uso family values soap opera

Pro Wrestling

The Greatest Wrestling Themes of All Time: Round 1 B The Greatest Wrestling Themes of All Time: Round 1 B

The Greatest Wrestling Themes of All Time: Round 1 B

Pro Wrestling

Connect
Newsletter Signup