Connect with us
Astonishing X-Men 5

Comic Books

Astonishing X-Men #5 Review

With Gambit now under his control, the Shadow King is spreading his influence! Meanwhile Xavier…has a heart to heart with Fantomex.

With the Shadow King adding Gambit to his menacing menagerie in the real world, Xavier lays out the stakes to the remaining X-Men on the astral plane. Elsewhere, the newly possessed Gambit and Logan are spreading the will of Farouk across the British populace and it looks like Warren will be giving in to his Dark Passenger next issue. Elsewhere it seems…actually, that’s it. That’s literally everything that happens in this book. I know the push for Astonishing is to be the action-heavy book in the X-Men universe, but this story is starting to feel a little light on substance. Precious little time is actually spent on character development, and while most of the cast have lengthy backstories, a little growth and insight may make me care a bit more about the conflict of the book.

Astonishing X-Men #5 Review

Don’t worry, though, you get some ‘splosions in this book.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Common conception claims the real agenda of the book is to provide a window for the return of Charles Xavier, and if that is the case, Soule has chosen the worst version of Xavier to bring to the table. In previous weeks we’ve seen the specter of Xavier attempt to recruit Old Man Logan to his side, only for the centenarian combatant to fall under the spell of the Shadow King. This month, we learn that he effectively sacrificed Gambit to protect the minds of Rogue, Mystique and Fantomex (man, do I dislike this utterly charmless and redundant character), which I have logical issues with. Now, Rogue is a powerhouse — it makes all the sense to keep the Shadow King from controlling her, but the other two? Neither of their power sets make them a serious threat for the outside world. Gambit can literally turn anything into an explosive, so why let the Shadow King get his hands on that kind of power? How bad would Mystique’s shape-shifting or that garbage person Fantomex’s illusion powers really be? There’s also the tone with witch Xavier lays out his discarding of gambit as if it doesn’t matter. Like, I get that Remy may not have been Charles’ favorite or anything, but there’s no reason to be a prick about it.


Don’t look too pleased with yourself, there, Chuck.

There’s also the curiously strong push to recruit the trash bag that is Fantomex (just really, a terrible character) to Xavier’s cause, which echoes his earlier attempt at bringing Logan into the fold. Like, what are we to draw from that? In earlier reviews I made the supposition that perhaps this isn’t actually Xavier, it’s just a segment of the Shadow King’s personality — and that may still be the case, but let’s assume this Xavier is on the up and up. The mental strain of maintaining multiple alternate realities to disguise his conversation with the X-Men from Farouk is literally causing his body to wither away, if the duplicitous Mystique doesn’t require this additional layer of coaxing, why waste your time trying to sweet talk the phoney French Diabolik ripoff in its own pocket universe? This sequence also weirdly takes place DURING another on-panel sequence in a way that totally disrupts the reading momentum. There’s even a textbox conversation that leaves a cliffhanger sentence before the internal Fantomex talk, then picks up immediately after it. It just kills the flow of the issue for no logical reason.


Ugh, why is this here? Come on, Charles. DO BETTER!

I should actually expound upon that last point because the storyboarding in this issue is all over the place. First of all, it feels like most of the pages in this issue are splash pages. Now, I lived through the ’90s — I like when things are big and broad, but the convention is way overused and loses a lot of its impact because of it. It should also be mentioned that some apps and e-readers have issue presenting splash pages on a digital edition, making following a lot of the dialogue in its intended form way more of a hassle. Then there’s the confusion of the Psylocke sequence, where Betsy telekinetically moves herself, the hypnotized X-Men and a crew of MRD goons from one skyscraper to another in order to escape the floor that the mind-controlled Gambit blew up (in context, it’s all kinds of mundane, I swear). The soldiers aim their guns at Betsy, even though she saved them, and she uses her psy-blade to slice off the barrels of each gun which leads to…nothing. You’d think these soldiers would put up more of a fight (or bring a sidearm as well as your assault rifle to your mutant terrorist threat?) but nope, nothing comes of it. Elsewhere we learn that Gambit and Logan can spread the Shadow King’s influence by touching people, so then why does Gambit threaten the helicopter pilot by charging up his helmet? The controlled individuals do appear to be zombie-like at first, so maybe that makes sense, but I imagine the Shadow King could swing it all the same.

Astonishing X-Men #5 Review

It is a cool image, though.

Outside of the framing issues that I previously touched on, the art is mostly fine. For a book that aims to be such an action-packed thrill ride, Ramon Rosanas’ art is a little subdued for my taste. There are a few strong moments spread here and there, Gambit’s exploding the ground and taking over the helicopter stands out, but there are a number of situations where the art kind of falls apart a bit. Xavier’s head is an odd peanut shape for most of the book, and his designs for Rogue, Mystique and literal dumpster fire Fantomex (I don’t like him, if you remember) leave a lot to be desired. There’s also this panel where Gambit chucks a card at Angel where Warren looks hella bored by this attack rather than concerned, which I’m fairly certain wasn’t the goal. The last panel of Angel shedding his skin to become Archangel was pretty cool though.


Warren: Yawning with concern!

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: Astonishing X-Men is written like an action movie. It’s a series built more around things exploding than making readers think, and relies on the legacy of its characters to hook the audience rather than giving us interesting personality developments. The story itself is fine, if a little flat, but I don’t like Soule’s take on a sociopath Xavier. Hopefully whoever handles the art in the next issue has a better handle on visual storytelling.


Astonishing X-Men 5
Astonishing X-Men #5
Is it good?
This issue is fine, honestly. The art is fine, the story is fine, it's all fine. There's just not a lot to actually get excited about here and a few logical lapses/storytelling issues that don't do the book any favors. If you weren't already going to pick up this book, there's nothing here to win you over.
The sequence where Gambit blows up the floor and escapes via helicopter is pretty good.
The flashback to the psionic battle between Xavier and the Shadow King has its moments.
The art is mostly underwhelming, and occasionally poorly storyboarded.
The cover art is pretty bad. It feels like something someone would draw on their notebook cover, not an issue of a major book.
Two things this book needs less of: Splash pages and that scumbag Fantomex.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

December 2021 Marvel Comics solicitations: 'Inferno' ends & 'Avengers Forever' December 2021 Marvel Comics solicitations: 'Inferno' ends & 'Avengers Forever'

December 2021 Marvel Comics solicitations: ‘Inferno’ ends & ‘Avengers Forever’

Comic Books

ted lasso 2.9.2 ted lasso 2.9.2

‘Ted Lasso’ season 2 episode 9 review: The complexity of Coach Beard


EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: X-Men #3 EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: X-Men #3

EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: X-Men #3

Comic Books

Marvel reveals new X-Men series 'Sabretooth' #1 coming January 2022 Marvel reveals new X-Men series 'Sabretooth' #1 coming January 2022

Marvel reveals new X-Men series ‘Sabretooth’ #1 coming January 2022

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup