Well, that was weird. Like Alfred Hitchcock mixed with Twilight Zone mixed with Elseworlds Batman kind of weird.
Excuse my language, but such was my immediate thinking upon finishing Batman #42, whose ending isn’t so much a surprise twist as it is a full-blown contortion. Given the circumstances of last issue, which saw Poison Ivy take control of everything and everyone in the world (except for Batman and Catwoman) to usher in a brand new planttopia — you’d figure more “weird” was to be expected.
Just… not like this.
Poison Ivy still exudes an air of indomitability, puppeteering from her command center/sanctuary of vines and ferns — and she’s made it clear that Bat and Cat aren’t doing anything without her consent. She’s got Superman on house-sitting duty for starters. And constant surveillance from Flash, Wonder Woman and whoever else from the Justice League she feels like controlling too.
“I’ve a Lantern coming, Bruce. Well, two Lanterns,” Ivy says at one point when Batman ventures outside of his designated boundaries, speaking through a frumpy old lady she’s possessed. “And Wonder Woman. Oh. And Gorilla Grodd and an army of gorillas. Just in case.”
However, Ivy can be a lenient empress-goddess too, as we find out when she allows Batman and Catwoman to grab some fast-food at the now familiar Bat Burger (which we last saw in Batman #16). But even as we glean new clues towards Ivy’s master plan (and a potential shortcoming in it), the underlying question still remains: why has Ivy allowed Batman and Catwoman, the only two people on Earth resistant to her mind-control, to stay alive?
That’s when writer Tom King throws a haymaker into the narrative that makes the right cross Batman gave Alfred last issue look something like this. And just as King has managed to do time and time again in his multi-part story arcs — he’s left us scratching our heads and wondering how the hell he’s going to bring everything together in the grand finale.
It’s hard not to feel tentative towards certain story choices, though. Namely, Batman’s methodology, which is reminiscent of the “tactics” he employed back in the “I Am Bane” storyline and far more reckless than we’ve seen the character act in any run in recent memory besides King’s.
We still have one more installment of “Everyone Loves Ivy” to go, though and if Batman #40 (the whole Wonder Woman cave kiss thing) taught us anything — one can’t adequately judge King’s work until all is said and done.
Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!