Connect with us
Valkyrie #1 review

Comic Books

Valkyrie #1 review

Catch up with what Jane Foster’s been up to before she re-enters the MCU.

With the recent announcement of Thor: Love and Thunder from the MCU, fans will be very eager to learn about Jane Foster and where she stands in the Marvel Universe. It is quite fortuitous, then, that Marvel is releasing a brand new #1 in an ongoing series featuring Jane, written by two of the best writers in their stable. Jane’s become a fairly popular character due to her time as Thor, and this issue is an excellent jumping on point for longtime fans as well as newcomers who want to see what all the fuss is about.

Valkyrie #1 review

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

The issue is incredibly beginner-friendly from the start, with an opening page that explains Jane’s backstory and origin in understandable, unspecific terms that are not mired in continuity. Her role in the War of the Realms and the taking up of the Valkyrie mantle is explained in three short sentences: “There was a war. I was called. I answered.” The issue continues into a fight scene, which is always a great way to establish what characters can do. This one has Jane facing off against Blue Streak’s gang, the Fast Five, who are stealing a ton of weapons from Asgard, Svartalfheim, and all the other realms. Jane explains what their weapons are able to do and why it is important that she stop them while displaying the abilities of her own weapon, Undrjarn the All-Weapon. The fight scene is light and fun, with the levity you’d expect from an expert like Ewing to bring with Blue Streak.

The first act of the issue established Valkyrie as a unique character, leading into the second, designed to establish Jane Foster. Explaining her recent cancer treatments and the fact that it has gone into remission, this scene sets up a new status quo for Jane as a doctor working in a hospital while also doing a great job depicting her conflict between being a doctor and being a superhero. It’s a four page scene, but it gets a lot done — Jane’s character is defined for new and old readers alike, her real life job is altered to change the status quo, and the loose plot thread from the first scene is followed up on.

Valkyrie #1 review

The final act is focused on establishing Jane’s ties to Asgard, and the role of the Valkyrie in that context. Jane goes to Valhalla to visit Brunnhilde, the last Valkyrie who was killed during the War of the Realms. Brunnhilde provides Jane with information, but more importantly she provides Jane with guidance on the role of the Valkyrie. Jane is used to being Thor, and treats her position as Valkyrie as another chance to be Thor, and Brunnhilde knows that Valkyries are not and cannot be Thor. Valkyries have a responsibility to the dead of Asgard that the gods never will, and Jane is forsaking her duty as a Valkyrie to act as a superhero. Predictably, based on her prior addiction to being Thor and the depiction of her struggle with putting down the hammer, Jane continues to try to forge her own path — a choice with fatal consequences. The issue ends by establishing Jane’s Valkyr-eyes as a power of their own, and setting up the villain of the first arc.

The issue is incredibly well-written and Jane is a compelling, well-defined character. CAFU’s art is great, providing a sense of realism with its three-dimensional nature while still able to depict the fantastical as is required in superhero storytelling. However, Aaron and Ewing are both capable of writing even better than this issue. The opening fight scene takes up half the issue, and takes the wind out of the pacing for the rest of the issue. The final page does not feel like a final page at all, and it seems like there should be at least one extra page at the end.

This is only a minor quibble, though, as pacing issues aside, this issue does an excellent job establishing Jane as a character and setting up the conflict for the first arc. For readers old and new who are interested in Jane’s new direction, this is an excellent starting point.

Valkyrie #1 review
Valkyrie #1
Is it good?
For readers old and new who are interested in Jane's new direction, this is an excellent starting point.
The issue does an excellent job establishing Jane for old and new readers alike.
CAFU's art is gorgeous, and Aburtov's colors keep everything looking vibrant and dynamic.
Jane's abilities are explained well, as is her slightly altered status quo.
The pacing for the issue is off, as the first scene feels too long and the final scene feels too short.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

the free fall the free fall

‘The Free Fall’ review: Chaos leads to clever twist

Movie Reviews

Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1 Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1

Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1

Comic Books

DC Preview: Catwoman #39 DC Preview: Catwoman #39

DC Preview: Catwoman #39

Comic Books

belle belle

‘Belle’ review: Anime adaptation of classic fairy tale filled with emotion

Movie Reviews

Newsletter Signup