Connect with us
Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense

Comic Books

Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense

More of the same. ‘Nuff said.

Every issue has opened with an “Ask Miss Information” segment where Palahniuk writes absurd screeds against himself and the fictional Miss Information. With each passing issue, these pages have gotten more self-righteous and indicative of the entire series’ self-importance.

With that said…this issue isn’t terrible. It’s a far cry from the consequence free insanity of #8 that I almost couldn’t bring myself to review. That being said, despite this series’ imminent end, there’s a lack of concrete tension or stakes.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense
Dark Horse Comics

The Narrator’s son, Junior, is now walking across space and time with a penguin who serves as our exposition bird. We jump all around, see some karate, a tiny bit of Die Off, castle sieges, and Japanese bombers. Random scenarios tied loosely together signifying little. Seen it all before in every previous issue.

Confusing, surrealist imagery isn’t a bad thing. Oftentimes it can be fun and a great way to convey exposition. Yet, #9 doesn’t push the bar its set even for itself, illustrating the stream-of-consciousness visuals with the visual panache of a, er, pancake. And I say this as a fan of Cameron Stewart’s art. We learn a tiny bit through all this, but it amounts to diddly squat: story-wise and visually.

If you’ll recall in the previous issue, Chloe, an elderly friend of Marla’s, was gearing up to bed as many people as possible. By doing that, their score would increase on a literal Die Off leaderboard. For some reason, comics take their general freedom and lack of censorship and use it primarily for orgies (see Deadly Class #40, which also came out this week). But wait! Palahniuk is pressing our buttons to the max! Chloe has sex with…Stephen Hawking! Egads! What a brilliant provocateur ol’ Chuckie P is! I can’t wait for this to show up in the next “Ask Miss Information” segment!

Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense
Dark Horse Comics

But beyond being toe-curlingly try-hard, this scene has no stakes. Chloe is scooping up points with no antagonist or force in her way. What if somebody didn’t want to have sex and clocked her? Shouldn’t there be some resistance to Die Off? What if they burst in? These are just ideas off the top of my head, but they’re better than nothing–which is what we get.

Thankfully, there’s a revealing interaction between Tyler and Marla where she confesses her feelings about the Narrator and their unborn child. While Stewart puts a lot of detail into the sexual escapades of Chloe, he shines the brightest across the three or so pages of intimate confessions.

Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense
Fight Club 3 #9 review: a brief history of nonsense
Is it good?
More of the same. That sums it up nicely if I do say so myself. Iconoclast visuals and scenarios continue to abound with the same level of pouty angst. Indeed, the plot is incrementally inching forward. But at this point…it’s getting harder and harder to care. Much less muster any indignation.
Cameron Stewart is great at facial expressions and drawing the human form (which we get plenty of).
Nice convo between Marla and Tyler.
More of the same rambling, button-pushing nonsense.
Palahniuk and Stewart can't pull-off exciting surrealist scenarios.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

'Nocterra' #2 cranks the darkness up to full throttle 'Nocterra' #2 cranks the darkness up to full throttle

‘Nocterra’ #2 cranks the darkness up to full throttle

Comic Books

'The Swamp Thing' #2 review: A war of ideas 'The Swamp Thing' #2 review: A war of ideas

‘The Swamp Thing’ #2 review: A war of ideas

Comic Books

Batman 107 cover by Jorge Jimenez Batman 107 cover by Jorge Jimenez

‘Batman’ #107 promises to explore the Unsanity Collective in a classic Batman way

Comic Books

Crime Syndicate #2 Crime Syndicate #2

‘Crime Syndicate’ #2 provides more style, but not much substance

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup