Connect with us
Batgirl #42 Review

Comic Books

Batgirl #42 Review

‘It ain’t over till its over.’

Oracle’s hostile takeover of Burnside continues. If Batgirl wants to gain any footing in this battle against an enemy who knows her every move, she has to start being more unpredictable ever.

In a funny way, Cecil Castellucci’s script and plot here shows the reader just how well she understands Barbara Gordon. By purposefully having the character behave in ways that she never would, by throwing out Batgirl’s “rule book” and showing her flying by the seat of her tights, we see a new side of Babs, one that takes pride in subverting her own usual patterns. It’s a fun take on how to beat an unbeatable foe, but specifically, it takes into account how Batgirl in particular would do it.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

The action sequences are thrillingly illustrated by Carmine Di Giandomenico, who manages to make the individual robotic enemies Babs faces pulse with a kind of uncanny life. Giandomenico again pulls off some wonderful acrobatic poses during the final battle, with Barbara seemingly surprising herself with some wild moves. As always, Jordie Belaire’s colors pull it all together, from the inhuman glow of Oracle to the raging fires coating the city.

Batgirl #42 Review
DC Comics

On the downside of this issue, there are one or two moments when all of Batgirl’s attempts to subvert Oracle’s expectations get a little muddy. We’re meant to see these two essentially playing chess against one another, and thinking several steps ahead, but there are a few times when it’s unclear who “anticipated” what. This leads to a sequence where Oracle is certain that something is a fake-out, but then seems annoyed and confused when it turns out that it is.

Again, a lot of this is due to Oracle and Batgirl attempting to stay ahead of one another, so it’s interesting to feel as behind the ball as the supporting characters who are watching this play out. It’s just that it becomes unclear in a couple of spots.

Still, the story moves along at a fast clip, with this being the most forward momentum this arc has seen since its early chapters. Best of all, it continues to pay off the newly-discovered facets of Jason Bard’s character. His involvement in this chapter is an interesting one that I won’t spoil for readers, but it’s great to see that Barbara is finally paying attention to the man she’s come to know at work, if not the villain she knows he’s capable of being. Showing Bard’s development has been an interesting tightrope that continues to work for this story arc in interesting ways.

In many ways, this issue provides several strong emotional beats that fulfill every promise glimpsed at the beginning of Castellucci’s run. It’s a solid ending that sets up a new chapter for Barbara and her friends, which is the best you can hope for. “Oracle Rising” may have begun as a tie-in to Year of the Villain, but it has culminated in a strong starting place for Batgirl stories yet to come.

Batgirl #42 Review
Batgirl #42
Is it good?
"Oracle Rising" sticks the landing with a bang and a hopeful final note.
The emotional core of this arc is surprising, but sets up interesting story possibilities
The final battle is thrilling and exciting visually, showing Batgirl taking some unexpected risks
A few of Batgirl's fake-outs are a little muddy, particularly in the ways Oracle reacts to them
8
Good

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

X-Men Monday #125 – Jonathan Hickman Reflects on the ‘X-Men Experiment’ and Teases the ‘Amazing’ Stories to Come X-Men Monday #125 – Jonathan Hickman Reflects on the ‘X-Men Experiment’ and Teases the ‘Amazing’ Stories to Come

X-Men Monday #125 – Jonathan Hickman Reflects on the ‘X-Men Experiment’ and Teases the ‘Amazing’ Stories to Come

Comic Books

AEW announces the Owen Hart Cup Tournament AEW announces the Owen Hart Cup Tournament

AEW announces the Owen Hart Cup Tournament

Pro Wrestling

'The Death of Doctor Strange' #1 changes Dr. Strange in a big way 'The Death of Doctor Strange' #1 changes Dr. Strange in a big way

‘The Death of Doctor Strange’ #1 changes Dr. Strange in a big way

Comic Books

'Nightwing' #84 offers great Batman team-up action 'Nightwing' #84 offers great Batman team-up action

‘Nightwing’ #84 offers great Batman team-up action

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup