Connect with us
'Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection' Vol. 1 review

Comic Books

‘Star Comics: Top Dog – The Complete Collection’ Vol. 1 review

He’s the world’s smartest, funniest — and talking-est — dog!

I’ve said it before, but Marvel’s Epic Collections are a great way to experience disparate corners of its publishing empire from times long since passed. This week’s deep dive is into waters I didn’t even know existed, with a complete collection of Star Comics: Top Dog.

Written in the mid-’80s and illustrated by Warren Kremer and John Romita Sr., I can honestly state that I never encountered this creation in my decades reading comics, even though the trade states that this character was “one of the biggest” names from its Star Comics imprint. Of course, I was old enough to jump immediately into mainstream superhero books in the ’80s, so even if these issues were on the rack, I likely paid them little attention. While lacking that personal connection to the series that may produce childhood nostalgia, I am old enough to appreciate a book centered around a boy and his intelligent, detective-minded dog. Better yet, I have young children, and since they are likely the target market for this property, I decided to have them read the trade with me and help in crafting this review.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
'Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection' Vol. 1 review
Reading her favorite issue in the trade.

For those unfamiliar with Top Dog, he is a super intelligent animal who meets a young boy (Joey Jordan), who promises to keep his new canine’s intelligence secret as they go on adventures foiling crooks, mad scientists and wealthy scoundrels.  Each issue is predictable but well illustrated, with clear lines and animated character expressions. Kremer, the artist responsible for most of these issues, created a body of work that sits nicely along similar children comics from the ’70s and ’80s. 

'Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection' Vol. 1 review

My daughters enjoyed issue #9, which acts as a crossover with Heathcliff (a character whose personal comic would feature Top Dog from time to time following this book’s cancelation). The issue touched on all their personal interests: a cat and dog rivalry, admirable comedic slapstick, kids running amok in a museum and living mummies to boot! They also appreciated issue #10, which guest starred Spider-Man; they have yet to compartmentalize characters by property and see it perfectly appropriate for the web slinger to show up in a book about a talking spy dog.

While my children were less interested in the final issue, it was a fine conclusion to the series, and actually leaves the reader with a heartfelt sendoff between Joey and Top Dog. It was an unexpected but fitting end to the run.

'Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection' Vol. 1 review

This compilation is a fine example of how Marvel can unremittingly recirculate its past creations back into the mainstream. It’s also a fine reminder to a weary comic fan like myself, that this back catalogue of characters and narratives continue to have life when introduced to a new generation of readers, willing to embrace them as new creations.  

'Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection' Vol. 1 review
‘Star Comics: Top Dog – The Complete Collection’ Vol. 1 review
Star Comics: Top Dog - The Complete Collection Vol. 1
This compilation is a fine example of how Marvel can unremittingly recirculate its past creations back into the mainstream. It’s also a fine reminder to a weary comic fan like myself, that this back catalogue of characters and narratives continue to have life when introduced to a new generation of readers, willing to embrace them as new creations.
Reader Rating0 Votes
0
Kremer's art is clean, focused and engaging.
Fun, focused adventures wrapped up in a single issue.
A nice book to introduce kids to comic books.
Similar to other like-minded comics from this era.
Very little in the way of supplementary material and details.
Ultimately not likely to leave a last impact on reader.
6.5
Good

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

Heavy Metal announces 'Chasing the Dragon' #1 sells out Heavy Metal announces 'Chasing the Dragon' #1 sells out

Heavy Metal announces ‘Chasing the Dragon’ #1 sells out

Comic Books

X-Men Monday #105 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, 'The Trial of Magneto' and More X-Men Monday #105 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, 'The Trial of Magneto' and More

X-Men Monday #105 – Jordan D. White Talks X-Pets, the New X-Men, ‘The Trial of Magneto’ and More

Comic Books

Marvel teases new series 'The Trial of Magneto' for August 2021 Marvel teases new series 'The Trial of Magneto' for August 2021

Marvel teases new series ‘The Trial of Magneto’ for August 2021

Comic Books

Marvel Preview: Marauders #21 Marvel Preview: Marauders #21

Marvel Preview: Marauders #21

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup