Connect with us
'Thor: The Deviants Saga' is not required reading for 'The Eternals'
Marvel Comics

Comic Books

‘Thor: The Deviants Saga’ is not required reading for ‘The Eternals’

The ‘big’ stars don’t show up until the end.

Most people love the Marvel Cinematic Universe, even many of the usually hard-to-please, old-time comic readers who are wary of Hollywood maladapting “their” precious source material. Even those who don’t love it might reap some synergistic benefits, though, as bringing obscure characters to a new audience often prompts Marvel publishing to reprint old, “classic” material, like histories of Taskmaster and Mysterio. The coming of the Eternals has even brought a brand new series featuring Jack Kirby’s space gods, from the all-star creative team of Kieron Gillen and Esad Ribić.

And of course, the requisite reprinting of old stuff, like 1985’s The Dreaming Celestial Saga and Thor and the Eternals: The Celestials Saga, from the late ’70s. None of that is actual Kirby stuff, but it fits well enough into his narrative — unlike, perhaps, the recently republished five-issue mini-series from 2012, Thor: The Deviants Saga.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!
Thor: The Deviants Saga page one

Marvel Comics

Stretching the movie connection (and the very definition of the word “saga”) to its absolute limits, Robert Rodi and Stephen Segovia’s story is a globe-trotting tale that features some hyper-obscure characters. The “well-known” Eternals like Ikaris and Sersi were previously taken out, leaving Thor to heed battle with Virako (who’s made a grand total of 11 comics appearances) and Gilgamesh, who has completely changed his appearance and is now literally calling himself “the Forgotten One.”

As you might expect, the heroes are opposed by the Eternals’ … well, eternal enemies, the Deviants. In the grand old tradition, the Deviants are villains mostly because they’re ugly, and that concept is brought up way more than you’d think it would be in a book that’s only nine years old. Even those gross, sea-dwelling monsters are fielding the B-team for this one, as Ghaur (perhaps best known for his role in the original Atlantis Attacks) is usurped by the surprisingly sexy Ereshkigal (who clocks in at 29 appearances, if you’re keeping score).

Ereshkigal confronts Thor in the ruins of Asgard, and steals a MacGuffin that would make the Infinity Gauntlet blush — the “unbinding stone,” brought to the Realm Eternal (see what I did there?) for safekeeping by the bauble’s accidental, interdimensional creator. Ereshkigal thinks it will kickstart Deviant evolution (or something), but doesn’t realize its sole purpose is to unravel an entire universe. Maybe put a warning label on that?

Thor and the Eternal Phastos (a superstar at 37 appearances!) take off in pursuit, and since the stakes are so high, they have to make pit stops at the Savage Land and Phastos’ former house first. Seriously, that second one could have been really touching and powerful if it were expanded more, but in The Deviants Saga it’s a waste of time for someone to be melancholy when there is much, much more on the line. There are many more of these strange lapses in logic.

'Thor: The Deviants Saga' is not required reading for 'The Eternals'

Marvel Comics

And Stephen Segovia really hasn’t hit his stride as a penciller, yet. It kind of seems like he’s trying to ape Leinil Francis Yu, and all the characters look like they’re squinting. The colors brought by Andy Troy, John Rauch, and Wil Quintana are rather drab, and fail to accentuate Segovia’s lines.

Thor: The Deviants Saga is probably one movie tie-in too many if you’re looking to go down an Eternals rabbit hole before the film debuts. Probably best left buried under an Asgardian throne room.

'Thor: The Deviants Saga' is not required reading for 'The Eternals'
‘Thor: The Deviants Saga’ is not required reading for ‘The Eternals’
Thor: The Deivants Saga
A disjointed romp with poor flow and characters you'll probably never see again.
Reader Rating0 Votes
0
The "unbinding stone" is a neat idea
D-list characters
Scattershot narrative
Segovia had not yet grown into the artist he is today
5.5
Average

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

X-Men Monday #104 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Factor, Election Meddling, Wanda Maximoff and More X-Men Monday #104 - Jordan D. White Talks X-Factor, Election Meddling, Wanda Maximoff and More

X-Men Monday #104 – Jordan D. White Talks X-Factor, Election Meddling, Wanda Maximoff and More

Comic Books

Heroes Reborn #1 Heroes Reborn #1

“Heroes Reborn” #1 is the delightful start of a nutty summer event

Comic Books

Man-Bat #4 Man-Bat #4

‘Man-Bat’ #4 keeps the thrills and the tragedy coming

Comic Books

Crime Syndicate #3 Crime Syndicate #3

‘Crime Syndicate’ #3 seeks to overcome the series’ initial problems

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup