Connect with us
Underwinter #5 Review

Comic Books

Underwinter #5 Review

The musically themed horror series reaches its penultimate issue.

The penultimate issue of Underwinter looks to the characters’ pasts as it preps for a final showdown. Is it good?

This issue finds the quartet of protagonists back at the mysterious manor shortly before their last performance. The events here flash back and forth between the characters’ present situations and their childhoods, giving the reader glimpses of each musician’s most ingrained neuroses and the emotional mistreatment that contributed to said anxieties. This focus on the characters’ mental well-being is crucial given the type of horror series Underwinter is. This issue further solidifies what previous issues already implied: it’s not just the supernatural elements at play here that are to be feared. Rather, it’s the human interaction with said unnatural phenomena that successfully make this horror story both scary and emotionally gripping.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Artistically, creator Ray Fawkes is at the top of his game here. Underwinter has delivered stand-out visuals from the get-go, but this issue’s art is the series’ most emotionally expressive and well-crafted thus far. Fawkes frequently makes effective decisions regarding angles and points of view that help to visually reinforce the plot’s sense of delirium. This is especially true where Eleanor and Stephanie’s portions of the narrative are concerned. The texture in Fawkes’ work is notable, as the ink spewing from Eleanor’s body conveys a similar sensation to more traditional horror usage of blood without feeling so obvious. The seeping ink (as well as glassy ice in other parts of the issue) also works well thematically as a visual representation of the existential rot wearing away at the characters’ psyches as well as the world they live in.
Underwinter #5 Review

The only cons I can think of for this issue are theoretical and based on personal tastes. If you’re the type of person who largely prefers for their fiction to move the plot along quickly and explicitly and who doesn’t care for work that is comprised primarily of relatively slow character development, then this issue likely isn’t going to wow you. But if you don’t mind its style of storytelling and spending time following characters’ flashbacks while being in the dark on some plot details, then this issue delivers high quality work.

Underwinter #5 mixes extensive character exploration, psychological horror trappings, and bold artistic design choices to create the series’ strongest installment to date. From the dialogue to the compositions to the color theory throughout, every detail at play here shines. It’s probably fair to say that Underwinter occupies a particular niche, but if said niche is one you enjoy then this issue will knock your socks off.

Underwinter #5 Review
Underwinter #5
Is it good?
From beautifully textured art to succinct explorations of each character's inner demons, Underwinter #5 is a penultimate issue that perfectly sets the stage for the upcoming finale.
The ice and ink throughout are both stunning visuals and metaphorically impactful
The flashback/present-day coloration choices (especially the bold reds and blacks) are striking
Various artistic decisions help reinforce the plot's sense of delirium and distortion
If you can't stand slow-moving series, Underwinter likely won't strike your fancy

Become a patron today to get exclusive perks, like access to our exclusive Discord community and our monthly comic book club, ad-free browsing on, a physical trade paperback sent to your house every month, and more!


In Case You Missed It

billy the kid 4.1 billy the kid 4.1

‘Billy the Kid’ episode 4 review: A difficult life on the run


Bryan Danielson suffers leg injury at AEW Rampage tapings Bryan Danielson suffers leg injury at AEW Rampage tapings

Bryan Danielson suffers leg injury at AEW Rampage tapings

Pro Wrestling

73 year-old Ric Flair will wrestle one last match this July 73 year-old Ric Flair will wrestle one last match this July

73 year-old Ric Flair will wrestle one last match this July

Pro Wrestling

'Savage Avengers' #1 is a strong character-focused action frenzy 'Savage Avengers' #1 is a strong character-focused action frenzy

‘Savage Avengers’ #1 is a strong character-focused action frenzy

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup