Connect with us
'Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants' review: Legion and Cyclops, the sons of Xavier, face off!

Comic Books

‘Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants’ review: Legion and Cyclops, the sons of Xavier, face off!

It’s the fight of the century: Legion vs. Cyclops, the sons of Xavier… who you got?

Having reviewed Legion: Son of X volumes 1 and 2, I’m happy to report that in Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants, the series finally hits its stride. And yes, I realize that’s kind of a funny thing to say about a series that ended back in 2014.

But it’s true! In this volume, which collects X-Men Legacy #13-18, writer Si Spurrier and artists Tan Eng Huat, Paul Davidson and Khoi Pham deliver two of the series’ most entertaining stories. And as someone who was never a fan of Legion, I’m just as surprised as you are! Too bad there’s only one more volume on the way (expected to hit shelves in June).

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

We’re not talking about the fourth volume of this trade paperback series, though, we’re talking about the third. Spurrier continues to explore David Haller’s new status quo in the wake of his father Professor Charles Xavier’s death. David wants to keep the mutant race safe, through his own proactive means, while trying to sort out all mutant-powered personalities that reside in his head. Despite the fact that David can’t seem to stay out of control, he’s formed a romantic relationship with Blindfold, one of the students from Wolverine’s Jean Grey School.

The first story arc in this collection, “Hope and Glory,” is a ton of fun–especially for fans of Marvel heroes and villains from the U.K. Chamber, Psylocke, Captain Britain–they all make appearances–even Alchemy! Remember Alchemy, Death of X fans? And then there’s fan-favorite Warren Ellis creation Pete Wisdom, who serves as David’s foil for this arc… and boy is it entertaining. Spurrier’s British, so you just know he’s having a ball playing with all these English characters throwing around British slang.'Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants' review: Legion and Cyclops, the sons of Xavier, face off!In this particular story, we get to see David’s rather unconventional approach to solving England’s mutant intolerance problem once and for all. He’s certainly not Professor X, but maybe that’s a good thing.

David’s English adventure is followed by a rather heavy one-off issue featuring his mother Gabrielle, which sets him out on his next mission–confronting the man who took his father’s life: Cyclops (in full mutant revolutionary mode). Anyone who knows me knows I go bananas for Cyclops, but the three-part story “Wear the Grudge Like a Crown” was especially exciting for me because it takes place during Brian Michael Bendis’ Uncanny X-Men run, which I loved! Sometimes Marvel can go overboard when its characters appear in multiple titles (cough Venom cough), but this is a case where I more than welcomed an appearance from Bendis’ X-Men.

Because it makes sense. In addition to David wanting revenge, it’s pretty brilliant on Spurrier’s part to have Xavier’s true son and adopted son face off in combat. I just didn’t expect it to be raw, shirtless combat… but David and Scott are two of the nuttiest, most extreme mutants around, so I guess it shouldn’t be too shocking they went all Fight Club. But overall, it’s very entertaining watching these two, who probably have more in common than they realize, debate their visions for the mutant race.

If there’s a downside to this volume, I’d say this series’ art continues to be average and just not my cup of tea. By now, I’m used to Huat’s art, but his characters are just a bit too exaggerated for my tastes. Psylocke and Pete Wisdom, for instance, look as though they greased their hair down. Not a good look, guys (at least borrow David’s blow dryer).

Of course, new Thor artist Mike Del Mundo’s X-Men Legacy covers continue to delight with their quirky inventiveness! See what I mean?'Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants' review: Legion and Cyclops, the sons of Xavier, face off!Season 2 of Legion is currently underway on FX, but I can’t really recommend this series to fans of that show as it’s a very different animal. But comic fans–especially X-Men fans who missed this volume of X-Men Legacy the first time around (like me!)–should definitely give these collections a chance. I’m definitely looking forward to the final volume of Legion: Son of X to see how Spurrier brought David’s saga to a close.

'Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants' review: Legion and Cyclops, the sons of Xavier, face off!
Legion: Son of X Vol. 3: Revenants
Is it good?
Legion's adventures hit their stride in this volume's two very entertaining story arcs.
You can tell British writer Si Spurrier has a blast playing with Marvel's U.K. characters.
A Legion-Cyclops confrontation is an inspired idea!
The X-universe is full of different ideologies, and it's fun to see David form his own.
I'm just not a fan of this volume's art, which I'd say is average at best.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

the free fall the free fall

‘The Free Fall’ review: Chaos leads to clever twist

Movie Reviews

Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1 Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1

Marvel Preview: She-Hulk #1

Comic Books

DC Preview: Catwoman #39 DC Preview: Catwoman #39

DC Preview: Catwoman #39

Comic Books

belle belle

‘Belle’ review: Anime adaptation of classic fairy tale filled with emotion

Movie Reviews

Newsletter Signup