Connect with us
'Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man' TPB Review

Comic Books

‘Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man’ TPB Review

Drugs, missing persons, and Turkish delight. All in a day’s work for Sherlock Holmes and John Watson.

A family man has gone missing and Sherlock Holmes is on the case! What happened to Michael Williams and what is the connection between his disappearance and the London Necropolis Railway?

One thing that I greatly appreciated about this series is that it correctly assumed that anyone picking it up would be familiar with Sherlock and Dr. Watson, even if they haven’t read Dynamite’s other Sherlock Holmes comics. There’s no lengthy exposition explaining who either of them are and, aside from a few asides about the purpose of the Baker Street Irregulars, nothing much in the way of explanation for Sherlock’s world. I haven’t read any of the previous Holmes books from Dynamite, but I will be picking them up after reading this.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Like many of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s strongest Sherlock Holmes stories, The Vanishing Man’s resolution is surprising, but totally visible upon a second read. The script sprinkles the clues throughout, but thanks to Holmes’ cavalier attitude, they all appear to simply be bits of inconsequential conversation.

'Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man' TPB Review
Dynamite Entertainment

Aside from Leah Moore and John Reppion’s well-written mystery and Julius Ohta’s gracefully-illustrated action sequences (there’s a particularly excellent fight in an opium den), this miniseries really shines when it comes to its character work.

This series has a firm grasp on what makes Holmes so compelling. I love the glimpses at Holmes’s nihilism that are peppered throughout the story. There’s a delicate balance being struck, showing that he is genuinely invested in solving the case, but he will not suffer fools. When he’s told that the fellow who has disappeared was kind, generous, and upstanding, he can’t help sniffing at the idea of a “perfect” gentleman. Holmes is damaged. If he can’t find a challenge worthy of his intellect, then he’ll dull his mind with drugs. He’s in a low point and he’s seen enough of the world’s ugliness to be more than a little hesitant to believe that people can be better.

Holmes needs John Watson to act as his conscience, which Watson does on several occasions in this story. The Vanishing Man presents Watson as a man who deeply respects Holmes, but will not hesitate to tear into him if he’s being irresponsible for endangering others. He also abhors violence, but is more than willing to throw his fist when the occasion calls for it.

'Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man' TPB Review
Dynamite Entertainment

Aside from his preferred “seven-per-cent solution,” Holmes is a man also addicted to challenge. He needs something to stimulate him and he’ll seek it out in whichever back alley he can find it. The Vanishing Man presents us with a Sherlock Holmes who cannot be left alone in his own thoughts, which makes Watson the ideal best mate and sounding board in his adventures. Without something or someone to apply his skills towards, Holmes would either go mad or overdose.

Which brings us to Professor James Moriarty.

Sherlock’s future arch-nemesis spends much of this miniseries skulking about in the shadows, inextricably tied to every facet of the Case of the Vanishing Man. Moriarty is a subject of much interest for writers after Sir Doyle, since he’s not a major figure in the majority of the original stories. This allows Moriarty to be adapted in many different ways, depending on the medium. We only get a few scenes with the Doctor in this miniseries, but it establishes him as a formidable foe not only due to his intellect, but also because of his uncanny ability to predict Sherlock’s behavior. When even Holmes’ closest friends and associates can scarcely tell what’s going on in the detective’s head, this aspect of Moriarty’s planning ensures he’ll be a thorn in Holmes’ side for some time to come. I’m hopeful that Dynamite’s next Sherlock series picks up this particular thread.

Another fun characterization in this series is that of Inspector Lestrade, the eternally exasperated detective from Scotland Yard. His portrayal here brought to mind Inspector Koichi Zenigata from the Lupin III anime and manga. Harried, anxious, adorned in a floppy hat, Lestrade just wants to get results and is constantly flustered by Holmes’ diversions and half-answers. He doesn’t add terribly much to the story, but it’s fun to have him along.

One complaint would be that there are a few scenes that don’t entirely pay off. Some of this is explained away as being scenarios manufactured by Moriarty to throw Holmes off his scent, but it does occasionally feel as though the story was padded out unnecessarily in some spots. Also, there’s a subplot about Holmes’ irresponsibility regarding his Baker Street Irregulars that doesn’t entirely pan out. The story is resolved, but it doesn’t truly feel like Holmes was changed much by the incident. This could prove to be something that drives him in Dynamite’s next volume, but it reads as unfinished business at this point.

Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man is a fun read that gets so much right about its title character. The hints toward future stories are enticing, too. Hopefully we won’t have to wait too long for Holmes and Moriarty to face each other again!

'Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man' TPB Review
Sherlock Holmes: The Vanishing Man
Is it good?
This miniseries is worth a read for fans of Sherlock Holmes and serves as an exciting introduction to Dynamite's line of Sherlock stories.
The characterizations of Holmes and co. are on point
The action scenes are exciting and illustrated well
The mystery feels like a classic Sir Arthur Conan Doyle set-up
Some story threads feel like they aren't tied up satisfactorily. Only time will tell how much of that is intentional!
8
Good
Buy Now

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

X-Men Monday #111 - Anthony Oliveira & Steve Orlando Talk ‘Marvel’s Voices: Pride’ X-Men Monday #111 - Anthony Oliveira & Steve Orlando Talk ‘Marvel’s Voices: Pride’

X-Men Monday #111 – Anthony Oliveira & Steve Orlando Talk ‘Marvel’s Voices: Pride’

Comic Books

X-Men Monday #110 - Jordan D. White Answers Your Hellfire Gala Week 2 Questions X-Men Monday #110 - Jordan D. White Answers Your Hellfire Gala Week 2 Questions

X-Men Monday #110 – Jordan D. White Answers Your Hellfire Gala Week 2 Questions

Comic Books

Planet-Size X-Men #1 Planet-Size X-Men #1

‘Planet-Size X-Men’ #1 wants to be bigger than it is, but promises an era of expansion

Comic Books

A word on some recently published articles A word on some recently published articles

A word on some recently published articles

Feature

Connect
Newsletter Signup