Connect with us
'Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem' is a vibrant but predictable adventure
Fantagraphics

Comic Books

‘Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem’ is a vibrant but predictable adventure

Ties together five disparate Donald Duck tales with an ingenious framing narrative.

It’s been 90 years of Donald Duck, if you can believe it (and I don’t know why you wouldn’t). Since his debut in the 1934 Silly Symphonies short “The Little Wise Hen”, Donald has been a premiere character for the Walt Disney company, often surpassing the Mouse as the most popular character in animated shorts and comic books.

Alberto Savini’s Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem bills itself as “The 90th Anniversary Adventure”, though nothing much about it keys into any sense of celebration or retrospective. It’s a fairly straightforward modern comic about magic, apps, and Monkey’s Paw-style reversals of fortune. Rather than celebrate Donald’s long career in cartoons and comics, it celebrates Donald’s key character traits.

Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem

Fantagraphics

The framing is as modern as can be. After burning his house down (yikes), Donald scans a magical QR code while taking a selfie of his tragic circumstances; that QR code immediately downloads a mysterious app to his phone. The app is, of course, somehow a magical genie. The tech bros have gone too far.

This framing sets us up for five unconnected tales of Duck luck, touching on all sorts of classic Donald paradigms: superheroing, treasure-hunting, and domestic troubles.

Throughout five chapters, Donald wishes his life to be easier in some small way, and in some major way, this inconveniences not only Donald but all of Duckburg. In one chapter, Donald, hoping to be given a new car, wishes to be famous; it’s not the most direct way to get a new car, but it is Donald Duck logic. This leads to Donald’s superhero avatar, the Duck Avenger, becoming so famous that Donald finds it hard to accomplish anything beyond managing his fame.

Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem

Fantagraphics

 

His solution? To wish that all his friends were superheroes, as well. The chaos is overwhelming.

As with all his wishes, Donald ultimately must wish to reverse his previous wishes. These become a sort of teachable moment for Donald, though of course we know he can never change. The narrative formula becomes well-trodden – Donald’s wishes and lessons become routinely predictable, even if their zany circumstances never are.

Savini’s cartooning is a delight. The book is packed not only with surprisingly animated ducks, but with a lush and lived-in Duckburg. Everyone from Gyro Gearloose and Uncle Scrooge to Daisy and Cousin Fethry make appearances, ensuring that Donald’s life feels full and populated.

Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem is a delightful time, likely to become some child’s favorite comic book. It never approaches the heights of the great Duck comics, but it’s no slouch: funny, vibrant, and immaculately crafted.

'Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem' is a vibrant but predictable adventure
‘Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem’ is a vibrant but predictable adventure
Donald Duck: Magic and Mayhem
Tying together five disparate Donald Duck tales with an ingenious framing narrative, Magic and Mayhem is a delightfully crafted if simple adventure.
Reader Rating1 Vote
7.8
Beautiful cartooning.
Deeply endearing.
Showcases the wide cast and world of Donald Duck.
Becomes repetitive and occasionally predictable.
7
Good
Buy Now

In Case You Missed It

EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: Captain Britain 50th Anniversary Special #1 EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: Captain Britain 50th Anniversary Special #1

EXCLUSIVE Marvel Preview: Captain Britain 50th Anniversary Special #1

Comic Books

Three Worlds / Three Moons expands with three deluxe sourcebooks from Jonathan Hickman and all-star creators Three Worlds / Three Moons expands with three deluxe sourcebooks from Jonathan Hickman and all-star creators

Three Worlds / Three Moons expands with three deluxe sourcebooks from Jonathan Hickman and all-star creators

Comic Books

Marvel Comics announces SDCC 2023 booth details, panels, merchandise, and more Marvel Comics announces SDCC 2023 booth details, panels, merchandise, and more

Marvel Comics relocating to Burbank, names Stephen Wacker new editor-in-chief

Comic Books

'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' #300 is a milestone done right 'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' #300 is a milestone done right

‘Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ #300 is a milestone done right

Comic Books

Connect