Connect with us
Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review

Comic Books

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review

Jim Gordon gets his own Batman: Zero Year backstory issue and it’s all about the Bat Signal. Say what? Is it good?


Detective Comics #25 (DC Comics)


Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

This issue takes place 6 years prior to the current events in the DCU. You can probably guess where this story is in the timeline. Gordon is still just a detective, all the cops are corrupt and Batman has only recently hit the scene.

Speaking of Batman, he doesn’t show up in this issue really, yet the story does hinge on his actions. This issue is filled with gumshoe detective narration and when I say filled I mean it’s nearly all of the book. It’s also filled with a ton of Jason Fabok rendered rain, which is always nice.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review
Really love Fabok’s rain.

Writer John Layman has himself a rather been there done that story on his hands here. There’s a touch of ingenuity, like the flashlight Gordon got from his daughter that ties into later developments, but the rest is stuff we’ve seen over and over since Batman’s conception. That said, Layman writes some good prose, and Gordon is always strong, commanding and interesting.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review
Who are these dudes?

I for one always like seeing flashbacks of Gordon, because it’s nice to see he wasn’t always the grumpy older man who only gave orders. A failing in this story though is having all the detective work take place off page. It dilutes the prowess of Gordon and reduces the issue to him recounting events that aren’t so exciting. The backup does tie in nicely with the flashlight storyline, but why it contains Man-Bat is anyone’s guess. Maybe he’s featured in the next issue?

Artist Jason Fabok does an exceptional job with what he’s given here. Everything is exciting, well laid out and flows nicely. The fact that it’s a bit of a stifling comic (with limited action and mostly narration), yet still interesting to look at means extra kudos to Fabok. And again, I really dig how he draws rain scenes.

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review
I hope you like narration!

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review 6.5

Is It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 ReviewIs It Good? Detective Comics #25 Review
  • Well paced and well written narration
  • The rain, the rain!
  • Been there done that

Is It Good?

Not really. It’s been done so many times before and the only inventive thing is a cute little hook that’s not as profound as it thinks it is. Jim Gordon could have done more in this issue, but all the real work, the detective work, is off page.

Become a patron today to get exclusive perks, like access to our exclusive Discord community and our monthly comic book club, ad-free browsing on aiptcomics.com, a physical trade paperback sent to your house every month, and more!

Comments

In Case You Missed It

our father our father

‘Our Father’ review: Horrifying & topical documentary

Movie Reviews

‘Justice League vs. The Legion of Super-Heroes’ #3 adds new characters ‘Justice League vs. The Legion of Super-Heroes’ #3 adds new characters

‘Justice League vs. The Legion of Super-Heroes’ #3 adds new characters

Comic Books

candy candy

‘Candy’ episode 2 review: ‘Happy Wife, Happy Life’

TV Reviews

'Multiversity: Teen Justice' Earth-11 superheroes get trading card bios 'Multiversity: Teen Justice' Earth-11 superheroes get trading card bios

‘Multiversity: Teen Justice’ Earth-11 superheroes get trading card bios

Comic Books

Connect
Newsletter Signup