Connect with us
'Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts' review: Little golden nuggets

Comic Books

‘Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts’ review: Little golden nuggets

High fantasy meets modern tongues, but is that a good thing?

Scales & Scoundrels Volume 2: Treasurehearts is the story of treasure hunting adventurer Luvander. Lu lives with a dark secret that she has trouble admitting to herself, much less to her new friends. Unfortunately for her, revealing it may not be her choice.

Treasurehearts collects issues # 6-10 of Scales & Scoundrels. The story begins right where the previous issues left off, and the art immediately catches the reader’s eye — Galaad’s art has a Sunday edition newspaper comic strip look to it. The characters have large eyes and the pages are filled with color. While the characters are not drawn with rich detail, they are very expressive. Galaad does a wonderful job of welcoming readers of all ages.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Throughout Treasurehearts there are pages that deviate from this approach, though. There are soul searching panels colored only in grey and white and multiple scenes where the entire panel is filled with an unblinking eye. There is also an early flashback scene with a beautiful night sky that’s the highlight of the book. Galaad’s willingness to change things adds to the comic.

'Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts' review: Little golden nuggets

Treasurehearts is well written, though inconsistent. Early in the book, there is a very touching scene with Lu’s friend, Dorma. There is also great character development involving Lu. As she learns more about herself, we see her interact with her world and struggle with many choices. She is firm in her decision making, but is also filled with childlike curiosity. Sebastian Girner does a wonderful job of exploring his characters.

This characterization is not limited to just the main characters, either. The supporting characters that Lu meets are also filled with motivations and personality traits that are able to be discerned quickly. These characters are so well written, that they immediately appeal to the reader. Girner is able to do in a few small conversations what some writers are unable to do in an entire book.

One of Treasurehearts‘ greatest strengths may be its humor. There are quips, one liners, dad jokes, and even some jokes that are a little dark, but nothing ever feels shoehorned in. The situations dictate the joke instead of the characters having to force them.

The inconsistency comes from Girner’s attempts to stay away from typical medieval vernacular. The book seems to want to speak with modern verbiage, and in most cases it does so very well. However, when the book does stray into the realm of “forsooth” and “doth,” it has trouble getting out. This makes it difficult for Treasurehearts to ever create any tone and constantly takes the reader out of the moment.

Howver, the biggest problem with Treasurehearts is not a result of writing or art, but one of timing: the first volume ends on a cliffhanger that is resolved fairly quickly, and the rest of the book follows Lu in what is essentially a series of one shots. While there is some insight given into her and how she is changing, it also causes the book to just come to an abrupt and unsatisfactory ending.

Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts contains some good writing and eye catching art. It’s funny, filled with heart, and contains many compelling characters. The book is really good at times; it just lacks stability.

'Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts' review: Little golden nuggets
Scales & Scoundrels Vol. 2: Treasurehearts
Is it good?
Treasurehearts has a lot of good moments and even a couple of great ones, but it lacks consistency.
Great art that can be best described as "all ages"
Introspective scenes mixed with some humor
Inconsistent writing. Does it want to be high fantasy, sound modern, or poke fun of the genre?
Finishes an arc from the previous volume then just sort of wanders aimlessly

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

X-Men Monday #116 - Al Ewing Talks 'The Last Annihilation,' Storm, Arakko and More X-Men Monday #116 - Al Ewing Talks 'The Last Annihilation,' Storm, Arakko and More

X-Men Monday #116 – Al Ewing Talks ‘The Last Annihilation,’ Storm, Arakko and More

Comic Books

The state of Shonen Jump — Summer 2021 The state of Shonen Jump — Summer 2021

The state of Shonen Jump — Summer 2021

Manga and Anime

'Amazing Fantasy' #1 blends superheroes and fantasy well 'Amazing Fantasy' #1 blends superheroes and fantasy well

‘Amazing Fantasy’ #1 blends superheroes and fantasy well

Comic Books

Mashle Vol. 01 Header Mashle Vol. 01 Header

‘Mashle: Magic and Muscles’ Vol. 1 review: A terrific debut

Manga and Anime

Newsletter Signup