Connect with us
Dead Eyes #1 review

Comic Books

Dead Eyes #1 review

The dialog keeps the interesting concept from truly realizing its promise.

In the ’90s, a masked vigilante took down the rich and the poor. His name was Dead Eyes, but he disappeared in ’97 never to return…until now?

Within the first few pages, it’s clear Gerry Duggan is going for a meta story. Dead Eyes represents many ’90s anti-heroes made popular by the noodly linework from the likes of Todd McFarlane and Rob Liefeld. But then there was a bust and comics have seemingly grown up a little.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Dead Eyes is now a middle aged fella, Martin, taking care of his seizure-ridden, invalid girlfriend, Megan, while he suffers working at Walmart and nurses hemorrhoids. However, he’s sneaking out to start his work again.

Unfortunately, the dialog keeps the interesting concept from truly realizing its promise. When a black lady shows up, she loudly complains followed by a, “sheeeeiiiit.” When who I assume is the main bad guy shows up, his closing line is, “Find him. Have some fun. Recover every dollar you can. Then Dead Eyes dies a bad death.” I almost wonder if this is intentionally done to harken back to cheesy ‘90s comics…but it’s not funny. There’s not a spark of wink-wink meta humor.

Dead Eyes #1 review
Image Comics

I posit that Duggan is trying to be sincere, because every scene between Dead Eyes and his girlfriend are saccharine. Yet, these supposedly sobering domestic fights are rendered awkward by the dialogue.

SPOILERS: Martin comes back after crime fighting and Megan notices him bleeding. Unsurprisingly, she guesses pretty quickly that he’s been out punching dudes in the pale moonlight. Just to make sure us dumb readers understand, she says: “You can’t save me, so you’re taking it out on the world. But Martin…there are consequences. The world’s a different place now…” This is insecure writing. Duggan has to make sure we absolutely know what the themes are. But by spelling out these blunt exchanges, he doesn’t let us absorb the emotions that should well up and inspire us with thought and feeling.

John McRea’s art functions well. His angular style builds an oppressive atmosphere, especially when he adds plenty of little domestic details into locations. At times, panels depicting hunched characters recall Sean Philips. Other, more shadowy moments, remind me of Mike Mignola. Yet, the color work from Mike Spicer is a big let down, giving lots of scenes bland grays and browns. It doesn’t help that John McRea seems to fizzle out near the end, neglecting background details to a large degree, which really draws attention to the mediocre palette.

An artist who fusses over their work to an excessive degree would be better. Somebody who would truly remind us of the ’90s excess that unleashed legions of McFarlane clones/wannabes.

Dead Eyes #1 review
Dead Eyes #1 review
Is it good?
Insecure writing and dialog keeps this book's interesting concept from truly realizing its promise.
The concept is intriguing and we get a decent amount of story for a first issue.
Art works fine. Although one more in the style of the '90s would work better.
Badly written dialogue.
Art loses detail as issue progresses.
Dull colors.

Like what we do here at AIPT? Consider supporting us and independent comics journalism by becoming a patron today! In addition to our sincere thanks, you can browse AIPT ad-free, gain access to our vibrant Discord community of patrons and staff members, get trade paperbacks sent to your house every month, and a lot more. Click the button below to get started!


In Case You Missed It

'Spooky Archeology' uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more 'Spooky Archeology' uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more

‘Spooky Archeology’ uncovers Atlantis, fairies, mummies, and more


X-Men Monday #97 - Simon Spurrier Answers Your Way of X Questions X-Men Monday #97 - Simon Spurrier Answers Your Way of X Questions

X-Men Monday #97 – Simon Spurrier Answers Your Way of X Questions

Comic Books

Radford Radford

Enjoy *70* of Benjamin Radford’s ‘Skeptical Inquirer’ columns, all in one place


Demon Days: X-Men #1 Demon Days: X-Men #1

‘Demon Days: X-Men’ #1 review

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup