Connect with us
Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review

Comic Books

Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review

New tales of Saturn Girl, Lightning Lad, and Cosmic Boy!

The secret origin of the new Legion of Super-Heroes is here! After three inconsistent (and occasionally problematic) issues of Brian Michael Bendis and Ryan Sook’s new Legion of Super-Heroes series, we now get the new origin for the team in issue #4. This issue is written by Bendis with art by Sook, however Mikel Janin is this issue’s guest artist and inker on the origin sequences. Joining them is Wade Von Grawbadger on inks, Jordie Bellaire on colors, and Dave Sharpe on letters. While this new continuity does have a new origin with some interesting twists, plenty of the classic Legion origin is there as well. It represents one of the series’ stronger moments thus far, but I was left wanting more.

The origin story is split into three perspectives that come together at the end: Saturn Girl, Lightning Lad, and Cosmic Boy. In Saturn Girl’s perspective, we get to see a bit of her home planet Titan. The team went with a really interesting route here, depicting Titanian society as a telepathic collective consciousness. There’s some really cool visualization of this artistically. Saturn Girl sits in a gray-white void, and when she communes with another Titanian, their presence fills the panel with red. It’s a striking and unique way to depict a telepathic society. Saturn Girl is invited to join a Young United Planets initiative after she writes an essay critical of the U.P. I’m not sure how I feel about this choice, I always felt Saturn Girl leaving Titan to join the Science Police gave her character some agency and informed us on what she was looking for in life. Ultimately this accomplishes the same goal however, and she leaves the Titanian collective.

Listen to the latest episode of our weekly comics podcast!

Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review

We next get a look into Lightning Lad’s past. Also featured here is Garth’s twin sister Ayla, a.k.a. Light Lass. The two are seen interfering with Science Police officers who are separating families. It’s a scene that draws very much from our current political reality and seeing Lightning Lad and Light Lass take this on directly is great to see in a superhero comic. Ayla is portrayed as passionately political here, which is an awesome choice. Where Garth seems a bit more reserved, Ayla is clearly committed to her ideology and stands up for what she believes in. When the two receive the same invitation as Saturn Girl, Ayla declines, citing the U.P.’s corruption. In this scene we also get to see their family. Winathians being born nearly exclusively as twins seems to hold true in this new continuity, however we see no signs of Garth and Ayla’s older brother Mekt. This family has two moms now, which is also great to see. Hopefully we’ll be getting some explicitly queer Legionnaires as well.

Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review

Finally, we are left with Cosmic Boy’s origin. We are immediately shown the robot dinosaurs of the planet Braal, something that goes all the way back to the first time the planet was shown. The art team has redesigned them a bit to mesh with this world, and I love how its all done. Braalian’s magnet powers evolved to combat these robo dinosaurs, and its something so silly that I’ve always loved. Unlike classic Legion though, only 1% of Braal’s denizens have magnetic powers. Its an interesting choice here, and Cosmic Boy is outright referred to as the one percent. Could we potentially be seeing some class issues on Braal in the future based around those who have powers and those who do not? Speaking of Cosmic Boy, Rokk remains a talented athlete, though his sport appears to be fighting creatures rather than magnoball. Like the other two original Legionnaires, Rokk receives an invitation to the Young United Planets initiative.

Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review

With the three now meeting up on RJ Brande’s ship, the origin proceeds as usual for the most part. RJ Brande is attacked and the three unite and use their powers to protect her. Though in this case, the new villains dubbed “The Horraz” are the attackers. Of note though is the invitation that brings the three together. Rather than being invited to the Legion, our three characters are invited to a Young United Planets initiative. We’ve seen a lot of criticism of the United Planets in its corruption and the various awful acts being committed, RJ Brande feels a new perspective is needed to solve the problem, hence the initiative. Whats interesting though is the implication that something had happened after this point to put the Legion at odds with President Brande and the U.P. Perhaps a more reformatory or even revolutionary spirit gripped the Legionnaires, much like in Mark Waid’s threeboot series. This is possibly the most compelling thing thus far in this new Legion book. We live in a time where our governments seem broken and ill equipped to tackle the catastrophic problems facing us in this era. To see a Legion of frustrated young people take action in response to this is both timely and necessary. However, I can’t help but feel this sort of thing should have been shown up front. This is the kind of feeling that can truly grip people and convince them that the Legion is something special.

We’ve had many different origin stories for the Legion across their various continuities. This team has crafted an interesting and engaging blend of new and old, but I wish they didn’t hold back so much. The kinds of themes considered here are what people need to see in the Legion and should be front and center. Ultimately though, this represents one of the stronger issues of the book thus far.

Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review
Legion of Super-Heroes #4 Review
Is it good?
This is an engaging retelling of the classic Legion origin, but it just needed that little extra oomph
Keeps the core origin, but expands in interesting ways
Janin's art is a great addition to these sequences
Interesting political aspects that could be expanded on in the future
Lacks that one thing to make it really feel satisfying

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today

In Case You Missed It

DC Comics unveils 'DC All In' line of comics DC Comics unveils 'DC All In' line of comics

DC Comics unveils ‘DC All In’ line of comics

Comic Books

Marvel set to relaunch 'Iron Man' on October 23rd, 2024 Marvel set to relaunch 'Iron Man' on October 23rd, 2024

Marvel Comics relaunching ‘Iron Man’ on October 23rd, 2024

Comic Books

'Incredible Hulk' #14 is awesome from beginning to end 'Incredible Hulk' #14 is awesome from beginning to end

‘Incredible Hulk’ #14 is awesome from beginning to end

Comic Books

Full October 2024 DC Comics solicitations: Absolute Universe is here Full October 2024 DC Comics solicitations: Absolute Universe is here

Full October 2024 DC Comics solicitations: Absolute Universe is here

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup