Connect with us
My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1 Review

Manga and Anime

My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1 Review

My Hero Academia’s first spin-off makes its debut.

My Hero Academia has been one of my favorite superhero comics ever since I took a chance on Vol. 1. Creator Kohei Horikoshi’s unique vision of a world where the majority of citizens have superpowers called Quirks provides ample opportunity for exploration of what it means to be a superhero, as well as what place heroes occupy in society. The series’s first spin-off manga, My Hero Academia: Vigilantes, raises a new question: what place do vigilantes have in a society for there are legal pathways for becoming a hero? Vigilantes is written by Hideyuki Furuhashi and illustrated by Betten Court. The series’s first volume, published by Viz Media, collects chapters 1-5. Does this debut installment of Vigilantes live up to the high expectations set by its parent series?

Much like the original My Hero Academia, one of this spin-off’s strongest attributes is its art. Court’s line-work is impressive on multiple fronts. Characters’ facial expressions are well-rendered and this helps sell the dialogue, especially in comedic moments. The volume’s action scenes are also well-drawn, and the flow of motion is stellar throughout. The main character, Koichi Haimawari, has a Quirk that basically amounts to sliding across surfaces at semi-super speed while down on all fours. This looks both humorous and dynamic, as Koichi awkwardly zips along buildings and streets.

Speaking of Koichi, he’s easily the best of the series’s three main characters. He’s always wanted to be a hero but he doesn’t have the power or skills necessary to go pro. As a result, he ends up becoming a vigilante. His costume looks believably home-made, and the design’s homage to All Might is great. It’s an adorable nod to an already known and beloved character in the franchise, and it reflects how Koichi was inspired to pursue heroism.

Unfortunately, the volume’s other main characters are much less likable. Knuckleduster and Pop Step are Koichi’s partners in (well-intentioned) crime, and both of them are generic in terms of personality and design. Knuckleduster is a mysterious, street-hardened strongman, and Pop Step is a highly sexualized pop idol for male characters to drool over. The team’s goals in banding together aren’t explained very well, either. Knuckleduster thrusts his mentorship upon Koichi, and Pop Step joins up for reasons I’m still not sure of.

My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1 Review

The plot may leave something to be desired, but the artwork is dynamic throughout.

Many of the trio’s interactions are meant to be humorous, but the jokes frequently fall flat. It’s hard to laugh along with characters’ banter when the idea of them casually sitting around and talking together seems unlikely. There are also several scenes where comedy is meant to be derived from blatant sexual assault, and these uncomfortable moments quickly squander the series’s otherwise lighthearted and fun tone.

When it comes to its villains, Vigilantes is a mixed bag. Most of this volume’s antagonists are individuals who used a Quirk enhancement drug called Trigger. If you’re an X-Men fan, then you can think of the drug as basically being equivalent to Mutant Growth Hormone. Most of the Trigger users seem to have been manipulated by as yet unrevealed forces, so none of them stand out as notable foes in their own right. We finally see a villain who isn’t a one-off towards the volume’s end, which helps build hope that the second volume’s conflicts will seem more consequential.

Also worth mentioning are two of the series’s supporting cast members. There are a couple of super-powered citizens clearly modeled after the X-Men’s Cyclops and Wolverine, and the references made are delightful. The pair is frequently at each other’s throats, and their powers are altered ever so slightly from those of the characters they’re based on. While the series’s main cast and villains lack depth, scenes starring these side characters are charming and hilarious.

Ultimately, My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1 is a solid but disappointing start to the series. The artwork is great throughout, and the concepts it introduces to the My Hero Academia world are fun to ponder. One of the main characters is likable, but unfortunately the rest of the cast is generic in both design and function. There are also several instances where attempted humor falls flat or downright kills the series’s fun tone. This volume builds enough interest to make further installments worth checking out, but if it didn’t rest on the laurels of My Hero Academia proper then it would probably feel less consequential.

My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1 Review
My Hero Academia: Vigilantes Vol. 1
Is it good?
This volume has a lot of strong artwork and concepts, but a generic main cast and several failed attempts at humor bring the overall quality down significantly. It's solid, but non-MHA fans can skip this.
Koichi is a likable protagonist
The artwork is strong throughout
The volume builds upon the base concepts of My Hero Academia very well
There are a lot of instances where the attempted comedy falls flat
Most of the cast besides Koichi is generic and unlikable
The handling of sexual assault is troublesome

Join the AIPT Patreon

Want to take our relationship to the next level? Become a patron today to gain access to exclusive perks, such as:

  • ❌ Remove all ads on the website
  • 💬 Join our Discord community, where we chat about the latest news and releases from everything we cover on AIPT
  • 📗 Access to our monthly book club
  • 📦 Get a physical trade paperback shipped to you every month
  • 💥 And more!
Sign up today

In Case You Missed It

DC Preview: Green Lantern: War Journal #1 DC Preview: Green Lantern: War Journal #1

DC Preview: Green Lantern: War Journal #1

Comic Books

X-Men Monday #219 - Ed Brisson Talks 'Alpha Flight' X-Men Monday #219 - Ed Brisson Talks 'Alpha Flight'

X-Men Monday #219 – Ed Brisson Talks ‘Alpha Flight’

Comic Books

Full December 2023 DC Comics solicitations: 'Beast World' busts out Full December 2023 DC Comics solicitations: 'Beast World' busts out

Full December 2023 DC Comics solicitations: ‘Beast World’ busts out

Comic Books

Marvel First Look Preview: Spider-Boy #1 Marvel First Look Preview: Spider-Boy #1

Marvel First Look Preview: Spider-Boy #1

Comic Books

Newsletter Signup